Skip to content

Is your property environmentally challenged?

Published:

By CHRISTINA S. PORTER

As developers scour our city for land to build the popular mixed use projects and artists lofts, properties with older buildings, many of them industrial, are being purchased for this purpose. The shortage of vacant land in our city is forcing developers to look more seriously at “environmentally challenged” properties. This is a very touchy subject and one to be handled carefully. When purchasing a commercial property all lenders, and sophisticated commercial real estate purchasers require a “Phase I Environmental Study” to be performed as a contingency to the close of escrow. It is in the buyer’s best interest to have control of this investigation — choosing the company to perform the assessment — to make sure that it is done by a reputable company, reducing the chance of contamination being overlooked. The last thing any of us want is a lengthy litigation caused by a poorly performed environmental assessment.

A Phase I inspection is essentially a survey that investigates the following: ■ Current and past uses. ■ Environmental regulatory actions pertaining to the property or to properties nearby. ■ Industrial processes on, or near the property. ■ Other factors that might result in some form of contamination of the property.

According to Harris & Lee Environmental Sciences, under the Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA), “the current owner of a property at whatever time environmental contamination is found — is responsible for site investigation and clean up.” However, a part of the act provides legal protection to the property buyer and lender if a quality Phase 1 site assessment is performed prior to the sale and an environmental hazard is discovered later. They also state that “this protection that is also known as the innocent landowner defense, depends on the investigator’s exercise of due diligence in performing the Phase 1 site assessment, because this connotes quality.” If the Phase 1 indicates the possibility of contamination then it will be necessary to perform a “Phase 2 Environmental Inspection.” A Phase 2 includes a subsurface investigation, meaning that samples of the soil are taken from random locations on the site and then analyzed for actual contamination, but could also include the testing of ground water.

If contamination is established, the seller must decide whether to remediate the contamination or to sell the property at a discount. It has come to my attention that this can be a difficult decision for many owners of contaminated properties because, if he/she chooses to sell prior to remediation, the price discounts expected could be great because of, among other reasons, the possibility of a longer hold time and remediation failure. Additionally, the possibility of a required seller carry back may come into play because it is nearly impossible to find a lender to finance a property that is contaminated. Another disadvantage is that a buyer may require extreme indemnification and/or risk-transfer provisions in the purchase and sale documents. However, advantages are that owners may be able to transfer risk to purchasers in exchange for a lower purchase price, without incurring additional hold time or hard costs associated with remediation.

There is difficulty in comparing the advantages and disadvantages of selling a property prior to contamination remediation. But Daniel Johnson, in a article he wrote for the Commercial Real Estate Investment Magazine, says that it may be more beneficial to hold, remediate and then sell the contaminated property, since the risk discount given to the purchase price of the property may exceed the future return on your investment. However, he stipulates that in a hot commercial real estate market, like the one we are currently experiencing, with excessive amounts of equity chasing too few deals and with purchase time constraints, the premise may not hold.

The bottom line is to make sure to have a Phase 1 Environmental Assessment performed by a reputable inspection company prior to purchasing any commercial property. (Christina S. Porter is in the business of leasing and selling office and industrial buildings and (310) 806-6104, or).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 13, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe