By INCITES By Ed Silverstein
The current rift between France and the United States over Iraq has left relations at the lowest ebb in recent history. Many French blame the split on George Bush. They claim he is arrogant and has shifted our country toward religious fundamentalism. They cite starkly opposing views concerning the death penalty, trade, the environment, missile defense and Islamic terrorism. Though I do not disagree with French on these points, it is simplistic to blame this tumescent animosity strictly on the President, nor should the United States be too quick to surrender the moral high ground.
Shortly after 9/11 the headline of French newspaper, “LeMonde,” gushed, “we are all Americans now,” but on that same day 80 percent of phone calls fielded by one French radio talk show were saying that America got what it deserved. Although anti-Americanism is on the rise, the French love American music, television, movies, fashion, food and science and technology. So why the recent hostility? I think one of the reasons is that the French are jealous.
Despite their excessive pride in all things cultural, France has been steadily losing ground to America. Ever since the French co-opted Alfred Hitchcock to bolster their autuer theory of cinema, their film industry, notwithstanding heavy protectionism, has taken a nose-dive that would have given any other country vertigo. France’s culinary supremacy, Michelin’s chauvinism aside, has deflated like a bad soufflé against a new breed of American chefs. Nor has haute couture made any inroads on casual Fridays. And let’s be honest, California wines kick French butt.
France’s economy also is a disaster. The failed socialist welfare state has resulted in 9 percent unemployment. A 35-hour work week has nearly closed the country on Mondays and Fridays. Strikes and work stoppages are rampant. Out of 15 nations in Europe, France has dropped to 12th in wealth per capita. And France’s faltering economy has resulted in drastic decreases in military spending; particularly frustrating for a country with pretensions of continuing global influence.
Though this may all be brie under the bridge, there is darker side of France that, well, stinks.
Though France accuses the United States of being a country of inequality, they have yet to integrate their own Muslim population. Most of these 5 million people live in crime infested ghettos and suffer from poor education and exploding unemployment.
The French government’s harsh anti- Israeli rhetoric (their ambassador to England referred to Israel as: “That shitty little country”) is likely responsible for the rash of anti-Jewish acts in France. Starting in 2000, several major synagogues and many Jewish owned businesses were burned to the ground, cemeteries were vandalized, anti-Semitic graffiti has become pervasive and there have been dozens of physical assaults on Jews. For 18 months the French government did little. Even now, though there is much chest thumping, few perpetrators are arrested and those convicted tend to get light or no sentences.
But French anti-Semitism is nothing new. Under the Nazi occupation, the Vichy government rounded up more than 76,000 Jews and sent them to the death camps. Only 2,500 survived. To this day the French have never truly acknowledged their complicity in the Holocaust and there are several top officials today, as well as numerous university professors, that deny the Holocaust ever occurred. It also is hard to stomach attacks on Israel’s human rights record by a country that supports Arafat, a known terrorist, and one that condoned the use of torture and murder to quell the 1957 Algerian uprising.
Even French opposition to war in Iraq is not all high-minded ideals. Calling for the end of the original inspections and subsequent sanctions, caused a rift in the UN that Hussein was able to exploit. If France and the UN had remained united and determined it is unlikely that Saddam would have thrown out the original inspectors and might have even complied with the current ones. And though France accuses the U.S. of waging war for oil, it is France that currently has oil interests in Iraq and they are desperate to protect them.
I also take issue with France’s position that the only justification for the use of military force is to defend a sovereign nation being attacked by another. This may sound noble, but on closer examination it would provide for no intervention were the holocaust to occur today. This might explain why the French were reluctant to get involved in the Balkans despite ethnic cleansing and the systematic rape of young women for the sole purpose of ostracizing them from their families and society. And what would France do if Saddam Hussein were again to commit genocide on the Kurds? Blame the United States, no doubt.
There is still much to be admired about the French. However, as long as they use the U.S. as a scapegoat for their own failures and maintain questionable opposition as proof of their continued relevancy, they will have little chance of being so in the future. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Comments and sources for decent foie gras may be e-mailed to:)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 26, 2003. Read the original PDF.