Skip to content

Jon Mann Santa Monica Setting kids up for failure

Published:

By Victoria Ciudadreal Brentwood

In your article on Nov. 1, some of the school districts claim they are being held to unreachable goals. That is just not true. We are setting up these students to fail by teaching them in Spanish and not allowing them the opportunity to be fluent in English.

My public elementary school didn’t have any classes in Spanish in 1980. My teachers found the time to teach me English when my family could not. I listened to tapes, read along with books and took practice tests every week. Within six months after arriving in the U.S. from El Salvador, this 10-year-old was fluent in English, and later went on to graduate from college.

“No Child Left Behind” is a wonderful title — it’s too bad that too many children will be left behind because we have a system that robs them of the chance for a better education. Why are the schools so determined to keep Latinos from learning in English and becoming successful? The article claims that it takes years to teach a new language to Spanish-speakers. I know from personal experience that you can give a child six months with immersion in English, and they can be fluent.

Why can’t Spanish-speaking students read the tests? It’s shamefully clear from the article that we’re not teaching them to. Why are the schools determined to hold these students to lower expectations than children from the rest of the world? Why do we need a Spanish-language test in California? We know that when these children grow up and want to go to college or get better and higher paying jobs, they will be required to have a command of the English language.

Coachella Valley Superintendent Foch Pensis should be embarrassed to admit that at Oasis Elementary tests show most students know less than 15 words of English. Stop wasting taxpayers’ money and resources on lawsuits and start teaching these kids more than 15 words of English.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 6, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe