By Richard Hilton Santa Monica
Ed Silverstein’s column, “Incites,” has come under attack by your readers for its purported “bias” and left slant, especially its unfairness towards Christians and Republicans. For the record, I am agnostic, a lifelong Democrat and, unlike many of my peers in 1969-1970, I registered for the Vietnam draft. My comments are about Ed’s Sept. 29 column.
The column states accurately that the main legacy and influence of Bush or Kerry will be his appointments to the U.S. Supreme Court: “Kerry’s appointees... will be centrist judges who reflect the attitudes of the vast majority of Americans...”
The last I heard, judges make decisions based on case law and constitutional interpretation, not necessarily or primarily on popular public opinion. When Justice Anthony Scalia was nominated to the highest court — he is undoubtedly one of its most conservative members — it was “centrist,” liberal Massachusetts Sen. John Kerry who voted to confirm Scalia’s appointment.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 1, 2004. Read the original PDF.