By Brad Jones Santa Monica
Assuming the quote is accurate (“Internal Slate Politics…,” Daily Press 11/13/02), there can be no doubt that Michael Feinstein wins this year’s award for disingenuousness, bad faith and dirty politics in Santa Monica. As one of “Abby’s people” who “bullet voted” for her at this summer’s convention of Santa Monicans for Renters Rights, I find it amazing for Mr. Feinstein to now claim that the SMRR endorsement of Abby Arnold was illegitimate.
In choosing to vote for only one candidate instead of three at the convention, I was expressing my choice that it was most important for Abby to be one of the three endorsed. That did not mean that other candidates were not worthy. It was a tactical decision on my part, within the rules, to ensure that my preferred candidate would prevail.
How is that democratic choice — to forego two of my votes — “illegitimate?” How is that “stealing the convention?” Surely an advocate of alternative voting systems, such as Mr. Feinstein, can appreciate such tactical voting, especially since he and his supporters did the same thing in 1994 and 1996. Of course, maybe if your side wins, then it’s different.
On the other hand, signing and distributing a “hit piece” at the SMRR convention which claims that a candidate is unworthy of consideration based on distortions of that candidate’s record — that’s okay?
Attempting to guilt-trip convention attendees into voting for one’s favored candidate because of her ethnicity, as Mr. Feinstein did in his oral remarks at the SMRR convention, that’s also okay?
Openly campaigning for a defeated candidate, who happens to be a fellow Green Party member, in opposition to the endorsed SMRR candidate, thus splitting the vote and helping to re-elect Bob Holbrook — also okay?
Who is kidding whom? SMRR and its current leaders have some soul-searching to do in the next two years. Abby Arnold’s campaign renewed a lot of people’s faith in SMRR's potential; it would be a shame if that potential is subverted by so-called “progressives” who claim to support democracy, but only when the votes go their way.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 18, 2002. Read the original PDF.