Skip to content

Keeping the Internet

Published:

safe from the U.N.

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY JOSEPH A. KLEIN & ERIC M. JACKSON

The historic “World Summit on the Information Society” convened in Tunisia this past Wednesday. And while the name given to this United Nations’ sponsored meeting sounds sophisticated and futuristic, in reality the delegates in attendance will be debating a measure that could put the greatest technological development of recent decades at risk. On the summit’s agenda will be several different proposals to strip control of the World Wide Web from the United States and entrust it to the UN.

History is the reason that the Internet’s backbone is run by the U.S. The predecessor for today’s Web was created by Pentagon researchers as a decentralized communication system that could survive a nuclear war. But in the ensuing decades, the Cold War gave way to commerce and the Internet became the world’s most important engine for economic growth and the spread of personal liberty. The 13 supercomputers that control the Domain Name System (DNS) that routes e-mails and Web page requests through the Internet are controlled by ICANN, a non-profit corporation set up by the Department of Commerce. Under ICANN’s non-partisan supervision, online commerce and communication have prospered as usage of this American invention has soared to 1 billion people worldwide. But although the results of U.S. stewardship of its creation are beyond reproach, the globalists meeting in Tunisia want to endorse a proposal to take control of the DNS away from ICANN and entrust it to a UN-approved body. While an impulse to “give control of the World Wide Web to the world” might sound reasonable upon first hearing, this rhetoric masks a dangerous agenda that American officials should resist.

The Internet is simply too important to entrust to the UN for several critical reasons. First, control of the DNS would give the UN financial authority over the Internet. Many of the globalist followers of Kofi Annan and Jacques Chriac have long advocated an Internet usage tax as a means of transferring wealth from countries to the developing world and for generating revenue for the UN itself. Operating under the belief that the Internet is part of what they call the “global commons,” advocates of an Internet tax have estimated they could collect at least $70 billion a year, according to the United Nations Development Programme’s 1999 Report. And the price tag today would undoubtedly be even higher given the Internet’s rapid growth since that report was published.

Second, UN control would almost certainly politicize the Internet, making international access to it contingent on political considerations. If a country ran afoul of international consensus, who’s to say that the UN would not change the DNS to restrict e-mails and Web sites from a given nation? After all, the vote tally in the General Assembly from 1948 to 1991 came to 55,642 votes that condemned Israel for one thing or another, compared to only 7,938 in support. So who can confidently say that Israel — or perhaps its ally, the often maligned only remaining superpower — wouldn’t be hit with a crippling ban on Internet access?

Third, seizing control of the DNS away from ICANN could lead to a fragmentation of the Internet — a technical nightmare in which individual countries set their own standards and apply their own toll booths. This is the approach that freedom-hating regimes such as Iran, China and Cuba — who were all members of the working group that planned the November summit — tend to favor because it would make it easier for them to censor online material and limit the free flow of information. In essence, such a scenario would take the “world” out of the World Wide Web and leave a cacophony of incompatible national Intranets in its place.

Beyond the UN’s ulterior motives and its known tendency of corruption, the move to can ICANN is simply without merit. The organization has shown itself to be committed to a non-politicized Internet with a DNS based on feedback from all stakeholders, not just government. With the world’s leading Internet firms such as Google, eBay, and Yahoo all located in the U.S., ICANN has far more incentive to promote the global health of the Web than the UN ever will. And ICANN is already a truly multinational affair — the governments of over 100 countries already serve on an ICANN committee designed specifically to collect international input. As the saying goes, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”

President Bush and the Congressional leadership should dismiss the nonsense that emerges from Tunisia out of hand and rebuff any Internet power grab by summit atten-dees, UN delegates, or anti-American globalists. The best thing for the Internet — and the world — is to the keep the Internet under U.S. control. (Joseph A. Klein is a technology attorney and the author of “Global Deception: The UN’s Stealth Assault on America’s Freedom.” Eric M. Jackson is the president of World Ahead Publishing and the author of “The PayPal Wars: Battles with eBay, the Media, the Mafia, and the Rest of Planet Earth.”)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 18, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe