Skip to content

Kerry-Edwards ticket

Published:

will be a tough sell

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY DAVID E. JOHNSON

One of the most charismatically challenged candidates in presidential history has selected his running mate, and in doing so has added much needed pizzazz to the Democratic ticket. But has John Kerry created a winning ticket and given voters an experienced running mate to pit against Vice President Dick Cheney? The early answer is probably not.

Discount the early polls that show that the selection of John Edwards is a popular choice. More meaningful polls will come when the glow of the Kerry announcement fades. Those polls will show that Edwards has not moved any states into the Kerry column. The last time a vice presidential candidate was able to do so was in 1960, when Lyndon Johnson carried Texas and the election for John Kennedy.

According to most reliable polls, Edwards will not be able to carry his home state of North Carolina nor any other state in the South. The Kerry campaign was aware of this when they made the pick. Of the candidates under serious consideration by Kerry, only Florida’s Bob Graham or Louisiana’s John Breaux could possibly have carried their states on election day for Kerry. Indeed, for all of the talk of a Southerner being on the ticket, the Edwards choice will have no impact on the South. Indications are that the Kerry campaign realizes this and that is why they have stopped advertising in targeted Southern states such as Arkansas and Louisiana.

John Edwards is a capable and charismatic politician with his stump skills honed during his days as a trial lawyer. Yet will he pass the late night comedians laugh test? Probably not. All of the Democrats who mercilessly attacked Dan Quayle (who has served in the House of Representatives for several terms and was in his second Senate term) will now have to explain how a Senator with less than six years of experience is prepared to be a heartbeat away from the presidency. The answer is he is not. One of the best kept secrets among Democrats was that no matter how much they were impressed by John Edwards’ skills on the campaign trail, they did not believe that he was ready for the presidency. His foreign affairs and defense experience is practically nil. In a debate with Vice President Cheney, those issues will dominate and play to the vice president’s advantage.

In selecting Edwards, Kerry also forgot the one rule in politics — don’t be overshadowed by your understudy. In this case, he doubtlessly will come in second in reviews on style when compared to the debonair Edwards.

Indeed in selecting Edwards, Kerry violated his own criteria in selecting a running mate. The key ingredients he argued were compatibility (it is an open secret that Kerry is not overly fond of Edwards) and the ability to assume the presidency (Kerry stated on the campaign trail only Dick Gephardt, among his rivals was). Then why select Edwards? Because party leaders felt that his campaign needed excitement and a boost with Edwards the ticket. Now the question is will there be buyer’s remorse? Probably so. For Republicans this is a ticket ready for the attack on the issue that is the president’s strongest — leadership in war. Kerry-Edwards does not seem to rise to that challenge. (David E. Johnson is the CEO of Strategic Vision, LLC, an Atlanta-headquartered public relations and public affairs agency with offices in Florida and Georgia. He may be reached at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 8, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe