■ What’s the value of a California high school diploma these days?
By Evelyn Jerome
Several years ago the state Board of Education decided that it would establish a high school exit exam and graduating seniors would not be awarded a diploma unless they passed it.
Seems like a reasonable measure — the state of New York has been doing it for decades with their Regents’ Exam.
Our schools and teachers should be held accountable for the education they are required to provide and testing students is the only way to achieve that.
We hear so much about “social promotion,” passing students from grade to grade without their being able to prove mastery of the subjects, we wonder if a diploma means the kid merely showed up for 12 years.
It would be nice to know that our kids are actually prepared for college or the working world and the millions of dollars we pump into our schools is creating productive members of society.
But last week the same board that created the exit exam voted to delay implementing it for two more years. Apparently, it doesn’t like the thought that some of our graduating seniors couldn’t pass the test. That would make our education system look like it’s not working.
Does anyone think it’s working well now?
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Jack O’Connell, a former state senator who endorsed the delay, said we haven’t given schools or students enough time to prepare for the exam.
What exactly have our schools been doing? A mechanism to test what kids were supposed to have learned during high school shouldn’t be a shock to the system. How does delaying the test help improve our schools and our teachers? Shouldn’t we use the test to assess where we are strong and where we need adjustment?
Have I mentioned that the exit exam is geared to a ninth-grade math level and a tenth-grade language arts level? It seems almost laughable to use these as standards. Why doesn’t the California high school exit exam match the University of California entrance requirements? Could they set the bar any lower?
Actually, they could. There is a movement to abolish the test altogether, allowing students to receive a diploma without ever proving they have earned it. Test opponents should recognize that the exam gives all students’ diplomas value.
After setting sadly low standards, the Board of Education took the coward’s way out, throwing the accountability of our schools out with the bathwater. (Evelyn Jerome is the founder and principal of Strategic Communications, a communications consulting firm. She is the past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats and a Santa Monica homeowner. To respond or to reach her, e-mail)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 15, 2003. Read the original PDF.