By CHRISTINA S. PORTER
Chronic lease violators can be a commercial landlord’s biggest headache. But there are ways to deal with them.
According to Marc L. Ripp, Esq. as written in an article for the “Commercial Lease Law Insider,” there is a cure for chronic lease violators. Chronic lease violators are the lessees who commit the same lease violation over and over again. But they always cure the violation before it becomes a default.
Ripp suggests adding a “chronic violations” clause to a lease that would allow landlords to act swiftly to rid themselves of a troublesome tenant. The clause effectively makes a lease violation a lease default with no cure period if the tenant commits the same violation more than a certain number of times over a 12-month period, allowing the landlord to immediately exercise his remedies.
A significant loophole in that scenario is that most leases require that the landlord send the tenant written notice before it permits him to exercise the remedies as they are spelled out in the lease. As most owners know, this will force the landlord to waste valuable time and money sending out the notice — defeating one purpose of the clause. If the landlord does not send the notice, he might lose the right to utilize the remedies.
Ripp cited the following example: The rent nonpayment clause in a certain owner’s lease said that the tenant would violate the lease if he didn’t pay rent within 10 days after notice. The lease also had a chronic violations clause that made it a lease default if the tenant committed two violations of the rent nonpayment clause within a two-month period. One month the tenant paid his utility bill late — in many leases utility payments to the landlord are considered to be part of the rent — more than 10 days after he received a late notice from the owner. The next month the tenant paid his rent late. The owner immediately started an eviction action. The tenant argued that the owner couldn’t evict him because the owner had-n’t sent notice of the second lease violation. The owner argued that notice wasn’t required before he could exercise his rights under the chronic violations clause. The court ruled that since the owner hadn’t notified the tenant of the second violation, he couldn’t evict the tenant. The court noted that the chronic violations clause incorporated the notice requirement that was in the rent nonpayment clause.
Ripp suggests that in order to avoid the same fate as that owner, it might be wise to add to your chronic violations clause so that you are not required to give the tenant notice before exercising your rights under the clause. Ripp also suggests the following “model lease language” be added to your chronic violations clause: “Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, if the tenant is in default under any covenant, condition, or agreement of the lease more than (insert number of times) within any 12-month period, irrespective of whether or not such default is cured, landlord, at its sole election, in its sole and absolute discretion, and without notice to tenant may (insert your own list of remedies).”
It is very important that you consult your legal council prior to adding or subtracting any language to an existing lease. (The above is for informational purposes only and not meant to be taken as advice. Christina S. Porter is in the business of leasing and selling office and industrial buildings. She (310) 806-6104 or)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 18, 2005. Read the original PDF.