Skip to content

Landmarks initiative will hurt community

Published:

By Nina Fresco

Guest Commentary by Nina Fresco

As a landmarks commissioner, I would like to offer my perspective on the Homeowners Freedom of Choice Initiative which would prohibit the city from designating parcels in residential neighborhoods as landmarks or “structures of merit,” or including them within any historic district without prior consent of the owners.

A supporter said that the fundamental issue here is “one of the freedom of homeowners.” Sounds reasonable on the surface, but this initiative, in fact, constitutes a loss of freedom for homeowners, renters, business owners and every other member of our community who has a stake in how our city grows.

Landmarking is part of zoning. Leaving it up to individual homeowners gives them unchecked control over something that affects everybody. This initiative is not only an attack on the specifics of the landmarks ordinance itself but on the extent to which different voices can be heard in our city. No one individual should have the right to determine something that affects the development of an entire neighborhood. No one individual should be able to choose to be above a local ordinance that doesn’t suit them. (No law that makes compliance voluntary is worth the paper it’s written on.) No one individual should have the right to prevent a historic district or single designation that the rest of an area wants but that could require unanimous approval.

The landmarks commission system is, in fact, very democratic. The commission is comprised of seven volunteers from the community. When an item comes before us it is reviewed in a systematic way. A professional consultant makes a report on the property in question based on the criteria set forth in the ordinance. We learn the background of the building, the builder, the owners and the neighborhood through this research.

Detailed descriptions of architectural features are included. If an alteration is proposed, the changes are evaluated through the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards which are nationally accepted. This research is standard and impartial. It is not based on beauty or, more importantly, taste. In addition, we receive a city staff report which studies the consultant’s findings and from there makes a recommendation. At least two commissioners a month are required to visit all the sites that appear on the agenda. Based on all of this information, we may step onto the podium with an opinion but the final element in our decision-making is yet to come. Public input. If these were not decisions that needed to be made on a case by case basis, if they didn’t require judgment calls, we wouldn’t need a commission.

Staff could simply rubber stamp projects according to criteria. The fact that people support historic preservation to varying degrees and the fact that we have the ordinance for the public benefit needs to be carefully weighed with each decision. How can we leave this important aspect of our city’s development in the hands of individual homeowners?

Public input is the most important and most variable element in the commission’s deliberations. When the commission takes up an issue, it is not considered a done deal at all. It is a decision to proceed with study. Is 18th Street the kind of street that we would like to protect as a district? How do the neighbors feel? Are there other types of historic resources that would be more valued by the community? We want to do the right thing for our city and we want to know what everyone thinks. These considerations cannot be the sole responsibility of individual homeowners who are planning only for their own parcels without peripheral vision.

Our landmarks ordinance may be finally coming of age. I hope we can see it through this crisis and that the thinkers, planners and organizers among us will see that taking all the power out of the law is not the way to improve it.

(Nina Fresco is a landmarks commission for the city of Santa Monica).

0 1 3D 2 48 1 F53 2 FAA 2

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 8, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe