By Beatrice H. Nemlaha Third Street Neighborhood Historic District Santa Monica
Editor: Seriously inflammatory misinformation about the scope of the Landmarks Commission’s responsibility to review and approve changes to buildings in Historic Districts is asserted in Gregory Poirier’s 02/26/02 letter to the editor headed “Be careful of historic district proposal.” I live in the Third Street Neighborhood District and was one of many homeowners and tenants who cooperated to seek designation as an Historic district in 1990. I am familiar with the ordinance designating the district. It does NOT give the Landmarks Commission control over “any” inside or outside changes to buildings in a district.
The Landmarks Commission absolutely does NOT have a review and approval responsibility for interior changes to buildings in a Historic District (although other city agencies do if building permits are involved). The Landmarks Commission absolutely does NOT have review or approval responsibility for “any” exterior changes. The ordinance which designates an Historic District spells out which changes do not require approval at all and which require staff approval. Folks who are interested in knowing the difference should get and read a copy of the Third Street Historic District Ordinance so Mr. Poirier’s letter does not needlessly panic them.
No one from the Third Street Historic District was forced to have paint or shingles removed from her property at the Feb. 11, 2002 Landmarks Commission meeting or at any other time. I was at the Feb. 11, 2002 Landmarks Commission meeting. Mr. Poirier misheard and misinterpreted a discussion about another city altogether.
Preserving and protecting the best of out neighborhoods and out past for all Santa Monicans to enjoy is a valuable and legitimate public function. The Landmarks Commission is entrusted with that task. I encourage citizens who care about their community and a considered balance between the public good and private property use rights to get themselves informed about how Santa Monica, other cities, California and other stated, and our federal government handle issues of preservation of historic resources. A good place to start would be to read materials made available by the Landmarks commission, including the Santa Monica Landmarks Ordinance and the Third Street Neighborhood Historic District Ordinance.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 1, 2002. Read the original PDF.