HIP TO BE SQUARE
By CAROLINE BODKIN
My last major “who am I?” identity crisis began during the fall of my sophomore year in college. In the company of my friends, their talents and vibrant personalities, I began to feel plain. I saw the things they did and wondered why I didn’t do any of those things. I was missing something.
I asked myself: Why don’t I play a sport? Why aren’t I majoring in political science? Why did I give up my radio show and the saxophone and horseback riding? What makes me special? What is my talent, my “thing?” I must not have one, because if I did, wouldn’t it be obvious? If I had a “thing,” I’d know where to fit in.
And if I fit in, I’d feel accepted. If I felt accepted, I’d believe I was worth knowing.
What makes me worth knowing? Because I didn’t have any idea what my thing was, I decided I’d adopt other peoples’. I tried out and did not make the JV soccer team. I bought a mountain bike and rode constantly until the bike was stolen. I borrowed hairstyles and catch phrases from people I thought were cool.
And finally, when none of those things were able to define who I was, and I was still self-conscious and confused, my best friend said to me, “Caroline, you’re not like everyone else because you’re you. You are your thing.”
She said it, but I couldn’t hear it at the time. It was the kind of wisdom you must learn for yourself.
So I kept looking for acceptance. And since I wasn’t getting it from myself, I was desperate to get it from someone else.
That spring, I fell in love with a senior nicknamed Shakes. He was handsome but sullen, brooding, tall and smart. And though he loved me too, we broke up before the school year ended. He was feeling that way that graduates tend to feel — unwilling to be responsible to anyone for the decisions they’re about to make. It’s understandable.
Needless to say, though I understood the reasoning, I was devastated. And for the rest of the school year I behaved like a complete idiot. I drank too much. I became quiet and insular. I cut off all my hair. I danced a lot and wrote a lot, which was good, but I was a bitch to be around.
And finally, the last week of school, I hooked up with one of my best friends’ crushes. The guy she’d talked about all year.
The morning after, I walked out into the common room of my suite, and the room fell silent. None of my friends knew what to say to me. I can’t remember a time I felt that hollow.
That summer, once I reclaimed some of my senses and realized how horrible I felt, I apologized profusely to my friend. I tried to explain to her that it wasn’t an act of malice, that I didn’t mean to hurt her, that it wasn’t personal, that I was just in a dark, dark spot.
There are probably a lot of psychological explanations for why I chose that as a remedy to my problems: Finding acceptance from men excuses you from accepting yourself, or something of the sort.
Regardless, it hurt me and my friendship, and failed to remedy anything else.
I got a phone call from that friend yesterday. She was returning the “Happy Birthday” message I’d left her. We chatted and laughed, and we made plans to visit each other in our respective cities, and it was great. We’re over it. It took time, but we got over it. We got over it, but I’ll never forget it.
I think about it almost every time I think about her. Still. Because remembering an instance when you were such a bad friend is a hard thing to forget.
That seems like a long time ago. I don’t know how I became comfortable with myself after all. Maybe it just took years of being the adult version of myself, or pursuing things that interest me, being a better friend — the kind of friend who wouldn’t betray someone like that again.
I don’t know. Maybe it took coming that close to losing a friendship to realize that there was a better self in me worth knowing. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and wonders daily if she’ll miss her calling. You can ).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 18, 2004. Read the original PDF.