30 years later
By GUEST COMMENTARY BY JOHN MARCIANO
Thirty years ago, on April 30, 1975, the US-Vietnam War ended, leaving a legacy of death, destruction and shame.
Total war dead: Nearly 2,300,000, including 1,921,000 Vietnamese, with 3,200,000 wounded and 14,300,000 refugees overall. About 15,500,000 tons of bombs, ground and naval munitions landed on Vietnam, compared to 6,000,000 tons of air and ground munitions the U.S. used in all of World War II and 18,000,000 gallons of poisonous herbicides were sprayed over South Vietnam, according to the Indochina Newsletter, spring-summer 2000.
There has long been a concerted effort to portray the Vietnam War as a noble effort that went astray. Anthony Lewis, former columnist for the New York Times, asserted that it began with “blundering efforts to do good” but by 1969 it had become “clear to most of the world — and most Americans — that the intervention had been a disastrous mistake.” Noam Chomsky, our leading intellectual-activist, disagrees, siding with the U.S. public that concluded the war was “fundamentally wrong and immoral.” The revised history has cast the “liberal” media that steadfastly supported the crusade as staunch opponents of the conflict. The mainstream media advocated U.S. military policy, and their criticism largely focused on failed tactics to achieve victory.
Opposition to the Vietnam War did not begin with student protests in 1965, but with shipboard GIs in 1945 that were diverted from their homecoming to transport French forces to Vietnam. Crewmen vigorously condemned the transport of those troops “to further the imperialist politics of foreign governments” and the entire crews of four ships condemned the government for helping to “subjugate the native population of Vietnam.”
The locus of the antiwar movement was within the U.S. military. Writing in the Armed Forces Journal in 1971, Colonel Robert D. Heinl, Jr. concluded that “by every conceivable indicator, our army that now remains in Vietnam is in a state approaching collapse with individual units avoiding or having refused combat, murdering their officers … drug-ridden and dispirited where not near-mutinous.”
U.S. military resistance within the ranks, coupled with the Vietnamese struggle against foreign aggression ended the war — not the domestic antiwar movement.
The devastating effects of the war went far beyond human losses. Arthur Westing, a leading expert on the U.S. military’s ecological damage in Vietnam, reveals that the “unprecedently massive and sustained expenditure of herbicidal chemical warfare agents against the fields and forests of South Vietnam … resulted in a large-scale devastation … to the (ecosystem), and in a variety of health problems among exposed humans.”
Historian Howard Zinn writes that one of the fundamental lessons of the Vietnam War is “the U.S. lost its good name … not only in the rest of the world but also among Americans... Many Americans learned that government leaders … could not be trusted. They began to suspect the most reputable of national institutions … of moral failure.”
Writing in 1975, Chomsky predicted the political reaction to military failure, saying that the U.S. imperialists who “suffered a stunning defeat” in Vietnam would now attempt to ensure that no “wrong lessons” are learned from the war or the resistance to it. “It will be necessary to … reestablish the basic principle that the use of force by the U.S. is legitimate, if only it can succeed.” Intellectuals and political leaders “may concede the stupidity of the American policy, and even its savagery, but not the illegitimacy inherent in the entire enterprise.”
Bruce Franklin, Vietnam War scholar and Air Force veteran, posits imperialism as the root cause in the war which began in 1945 when U.S. global domination faced its most direct challenge in Vietnam, the first European colony to emerge from WW II a claim of independence, a national government, and its own army. “The ‘imperialism’ story is the only one that adequately accounts for (U.S.) military, political and economic warfare against Vietnam and hostility toward every other colony and former colony that has resisted” the U.S. empire.
Daniel Ellsberg, former Pentagon analyst and Marine Corps veteran who exposed The Pentagon Papers, states he “understood at last that the war was one war; there wasn’t a French war followed by a Vietnamese war and an American war — there was one war that we had participated in from the beginning, and it was a war that we never had any right to be in at all, any more than the French did.”
Finally, the preeminent 20th century war scholar Gabriel Kolko concludes that we view the 10,000-day Vietnam War for “how devious, incorrigible, and beyond the pale of human values America’s rulers were throughout this epic event in U.S. history.” (John Marciano, professor emeritus, State University of New York, lives in Santa Monica.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 30, 2005. Read the original PDF.