By CAROLINE BODKIN
Message number three of four that awaited my return Friday after a day of lull began with the longest sigh I’ve ever heard. Then, “Where are you...” The voice was like the whisper that would follow three years of screaming from the bottom of a well.
“I’m so sorry things are this way,” the voice continued, and I began picturing this person, the person sitting at the bottom of whatever well he’s fallen into.
I see a man in an office, a tie leashed around his neck, his making this phone call from an office amidst other tightly tied men and high-heeled women. And all of them seem totally together — totally without need of this type of phone call. None of whom know the dank of a well’s bottom.
I realized the man had paused as if to allow for my reverie. And then he said, “I just... sometimes I want to leave Marcy so badly, I love you so much, but I can’t. It’s gone on too long, and you’re so beautiful.”
I had no idea who this man was. Didn’t recognize the voice, never heard of Marcy. He’d gotten the wrong number.
“I’ll be at Storm’s. We’ll talk about it in private. Call there to let me know you’re coming,” and then he gave a number to a hotel I remember seeing in Santa Barbara. A five star. The kind in which I’d imagine lovers might meet.
“I’m in room 526 this weekend... I have to go. Just — just call there, OK?” And the whisper stopped, and my answering machine moved on to message four.
Secrets present a funny illogic in the human psyche: No matter how many secrets we keep to ourselves, we still assume during regular operating hours that we are the only ones that have them.
The man who filled the gas: normal life. The woman at the bank: normal life. The girl at reception: normal life. We arrive at the classroom or site or office and greet the people with whom, every day, we exchange normal conversation and then go away from that place to face whatever oddities have quirked our own lives. We assume that the other people are going home to beef and peas and sitcoms.
Assuming that no one else’s mother is living with cancer but telling no one. Assuming that no one else daydreams of going home and setting it all on fire a la Edward Norton in Fight Club for just one breath of unattached Zen freedom. Assuming that the conversations behind the desks are all quite normal.
But here I was, listening to the man in the necktie struggle ever so quietly amidst his daily dose of “presumably normal” facing what could be the worst turn he’s ever taken. Or, at least, the most telling.
As for me, I was in a quandary. This desperate man called out from the bottom of his emotional well, and when he meant to call the one person he believes can pull him out of it, he got me. Do I call and tell him his message cannot be answered simply because it was not received?
If I call him and tell him, I propagate an affair that might end up hurting a lot of people. If I do not and if he lasts the night with no visitor — the shooting star of an affair might fade peacefully. If I do call him there might be love, which is more important than anything. If I don’t call him, he might stay at the bottom of that well for a long, long time, never able to scale the walls himself.
We wrap secrets tight, the heart’s most sacred dermal. We revere them for their dire importance. As a result, we refuse to tell people the most important pieces of our lives, but then we expect them to understand even the slightest bit of who we are.
For a moment, while I debated my move, I started to picture a world in which everyone wore their secrets like rock concert T-shirts: A beautiful young couple walks hand in hand, the wife wears the T-shirt that says “I’m terrified of pregnancy.” The guy in front of the Power Point screen wears: “I cheated my way through school. Every day I think I’m wrong.”
But this is not our reality. In our world, we share out of necessity, we’re discovered, or we’re lucky enough to tell secrets to the people we trust. And we are betrayed, or we are honored. We make enemies, or find lifelong friends, even lovers.
Suddenly I felt supremely relieved that I knew about the pending rendezvous. Not because I had the ability to call or not to call to make a decision. I knew that wasn’t my job. I would do nothing and let fate play its game.
I was relieved because their secret was free. Whatever pain or love came, or will come of it, there was at least one other person to witness it in its most vulnerable state. Before there were excuses for it. Before there was anger from it. At the time when it was just two people sharing something difficult, or wrong, or horrible, or confused, or good in its way, there was one person who knew it was out there. They were no longer alone.
See, this thing we go through, be it from the classroom or the desk with the phone or from the bottom of our own well, we do not go through it alone. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and wonders daily what messages await her. You can ).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 17, 2005. Read the original PDF.