Skip to content

Let molesters choose their own castration

Published:

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY CLIFF NICHOLS

Not many years ago, an adult male admitted to having had sexual intercourse with the daughter of his live-in girlfriend. When asked why he had done it, he responded, “Because she was coming on to me.” The little girl in question was 18 months old.

In the hope of protecting our children from such predators, all states now have combined some form of a Megan’s Law with Amber Alert technology. The former attempts to keep us informed as to who these molesters are, what they are and where they are via the Internet. Whereas Amber Alerts have been designed, in part, to help us to respond effectively on those occasions when the well-intentioned hopes of Megan’s Law fail.

In many cases, however, the truth is that both systems are significantly defective. Consider the case of John Evander Couey. On Feb. 23, this registered sex offender spontaneously, and without warning to anyone, responded to an urge to go “out” for the evening. So, he entered the home of 9-year-old Jessica Lunsford, evaded detection by her father and grandfather who resided in the home, and successfully secreted her in the dark of night to a location down her street where he then sexually abused her, strangled her and buried her. Who was Couey and why was he able to do what he did? Prior to that fateful night his arrest history included the following: Drug possession Lewd act upon a child Burglary Drunk and disorderly conduct Driving while intoxicated Indecent exposure Fraud and larceny How is it possible for a man with such a background to render both of our country’s national child molestation prevention systems impotent? It is because people like Couey are well aware of the defects and shortcomings of these systems and that knowledge, in turn, enables them to effectively perpetrate their crimes in ways that allows them to satiate their lusts unhindered until it is too late.

All who are not perpetrators themselves — and maybe even some of them as well — would most certainly agree that such a gaping loophole cannot be permitted to continue. A remedy is imperative. Jessica’s father is now insisting upon it. Similar to our response to the cases of 7-year-old Megan Kanka and 7-year-old Amber Hagerman, Mr. Lunsford is now rightly demanding these perpetrators be kept off our streets and away from our children. To this end he has proclaimed that, “(t)here should (now) be a law for Jesse.”

No doubt there shall be such a law and perhaps many. Therefore, before they are drafted, perhaps we should view this eventuality as an opportunity to be seized. Who knows? Perhaps this time around we can do it right.

Now may well be the time for us to seriously consider the enactment of a federal law mandating that all convicted child molesters in this country submit to chemical castration for the remainder of their lives as a prerequisite to their release from prison — a concept afforded legitimacy by laws already enacted to this effect in Florida, California and Oklahoma.

Criminal laws are generally intended to balance in varying degrees four purposes: punishment, retribution, rehabilitation and the protection of society. To achieve the appropriate balance in the case of child molesters requires that we first acknowledge the fact that they are by definition dangerously psychopathic people; utterly indifferent to, if not contemptuous of, our society’s concepts of right and wrong.

Once this is settled, the notions of retribution, punishment and the protection of society clearly dictate that child molesters should rightly be incarcerated for many years, if not for life. Such, however, is not the case presently. Figures released by the Department of Justice’s Bureau of Justice Statistics indicate that sex offenders in the United States receive on average an eight-year sentence and of that time serve only three years prior to their release.

This suggests that the lofty goal of rehabilitating these offenders has somehow been given priority in our sentencing decisions. But is this justified? Again, it would not appear so in light of the fact that the same Justice Department statistics indicate that 70 percent of the men convicted for sex crimes in the U.S. were molesters of children predominately under 13 years old and that, of all those released from prison, sex offenders are four times more likely to be rearrested for another sex crime within three years following their release. These figures would suggest something approaching a life sentence is justified to protect our children irregardless of anyone’s concerns about rehabilitating the perpetrators.

But can imprisonment for life be justified? Yes, if one compares it to the possible life sentences now available for kid-napping and then further considers that by comparison to many, if not most, child molestations, kidnapping might well be viewed as a far less egregious offense. For example, to prevent what John Evander Couey did to Jessica Lunsford upon his release from prison a life sentence could easily be justified. His kid-napping of this young girl was merely a preparatory act necessary for him to be able to engage in the truly heinous acts that followed.

Yet there are certain to be some civil libertarians who will disagree. They will argue that a life sentence would be disproportionate to the gravity of the crime of molestation, absent the concurrent occurrence of other crimes such as murder. However, that is where the value of making available a chemical castration option lies.

To placate the libertarians — if that is even possible — the law might be structured as follows: Convicted child molesters shall receive a mandatory life sentence from which there shall be only one possibility of parole (available only after the felon has served a mandatory minimum period of incarceration set forth in the federal sentencing guidelines) — if the molester consents to submit to the chemical castration procedure for the remainder of his life.

Moreover, to overcome yet another libertarian concern that such consent may not be completely voluntary, the law should not require that the election be made by the convicted molester at sentencing. Rather the option should remain available to be elected by the prisoner at any time during the course of his incarceration, subject to him having served the statutory minimum number of years. After all, why not let such a person have all the time they need to decide the matter for themselves?

Either way, whatever they decide the point is that our society’s goals will have been met. Our children will be afforded greater protection than they now have and so no doubt will be able to rest easier than Jessica Lunsford did on the night she met John Evander Couey. (Cliff Nichols is an attorney practicing criminal defense/entertainment law in Santa Monica, California. He may be contacted regarding this editorial at either (310) 917-1083, www.cliffnichol-slaw.com or www.cliffnicholsradio.com )

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 26, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe