Skip to content

Let’s put the funding for Viagra where it belongs

Published:

By CAROLE ORLIN

We all know that our government (at all levels) has to make difficult choices in spending our tax dollars. But a couple of very recent examples of how perverse that allocation can be struck me as worth sharing.

A flurry of articles appeared during the last week of May that focused attention on the federal government’s pronouncement to states that they do not have to pay for Viagra for convicted rapists and other high-risk offenders. Are you kidding me? Examples of Medicaid payments have surfaced in numerous states. In New York, an audit by the comptroller’s office from 2000 to 2005 found that 198 sex offenders in the state obtained Medicaid-reimbursed Viagra after their convictions for sex offenses involving victims as young as 2 years of age. In Florida, the attorney general reported that over the last four years, Medicaid payments of $93,000 enabled Viagra to be provided to 218 sex offenders. This incredible expenditure of tax dollars comes in stark contrast to a crisis that was brought home to me in a recent conversation with Julianne Sylva, deputy district attorney for Santa Clara County. Our conversation centered on the Child Abduction units that operate through the D.A.’s offices in each of the 58 counties in California. These units have not received funding since 2000-2001, when the counties received $13 million to carry out their objectives. Many people have never heard of these units and have no idea of their mission. They were established in 1976 when California enacted a law requiring each county to actively “take all actions necessary to both locate missing children who were subject of custody orders and to enforce custody orders.” The statute also authorized the state to reimburse the counties for the expenses incurred while carrying out this mandate. These Child Abduction units of the district attorneys’ offices deal with issues that range from simple visitation to international child abduction by a family member. They have the discretion to deal with issues either criminally or civilly.

As detailed in an article by Julianne Sylva and Elaine Tumonis, these units are called into action at the “juncture where family and criminal law collide.” California was the first state to establish this type of program, and it has been recognized as a model for the rest of the country. In an article by J. Chiancone, L. Girdner and P. Hoff, nationally known experts in the field of parental kidnap-ping, they state that: “California’s innovative approach to custodial interference and abduction cases is now being more widely implemented. The Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act… includes several sections modeled on California law that give prosecutors and law enforcement… new flexibility and additional civil tools to help find and recover abducted children.”

It seems that there is a widespread misconception about child abduction. Many people think that taking a child is not a crime, but rather an act of love. Indeed, custody and visitation disputes are among the most difficult, volatile and emotional cases that end up in the judicial system. However, we all read the papers and watch the news; too often, we see that children are taken for reasons of anger, revenge and control, and find themselves often placed in danger. They might be in physical danger, or they might be taken out of the state or country, their identities changed, and the other parent might never see them again. They might be told that the other parent does not love them or want them anymore, or that they died. An article by Ron Geltz, Los Angeles County deputy district attorney, gave a heartbreaking example of a 6-year-old girl in Arkansas who had been recovered from her abducting father. The young girl would only stare at her mother, whom she had not seen in two years. She told investigators that she thought she was seeing a ghost, as her father told her that her mother was dead.

Despite the critically important service these units provide, the legislature has not provided any funding for nearly five years. Eliminating $13 million dollars to the counties for funding these services became part of the package of cuts to make up a then $9 billion state deficit. As a result of these budget cuts, many units have had to scale back their staff and services. Many of these units have struggled to survive and have often paid for services out of their own pockets. A number of small counties have not been able to provide this service at all. Recently, however, they received some potentially good news. There is a possibility that they might finally be getting funded for this fiscal year. It is cautious optimism; there is still a long way to go before it reaches the governor for approval of the allocation of these funds.

The obvious irony in the allocation of tax dollars to pay for Viagra for convicted sex offenders is exacerbated when we see crucial programs like the California Child Abduction units, looked to as models for other units around the country, in danger of being dismantled. As parents and citizens, it is incumbent upon us to be heard through e-mails and letters expressing our support for funding of these units to our state representatives in Sacramento. We cannot afford to be silent. (Carole)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 6, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe