By Ed Silverstein
The Supreme Court last year stated that diversity could result in a broad social value and upheld the right for the University of Michigan to use race as a factor in admissions. Affirmative action proponents had argued that colleges were already using non-academic criteria by giving preferences to the offspring of large contributors or famous alumni, even if those offspring — as was the case with George W. Bush — were only average students.
President Bush, in turn, has incorporated similar factors in affording the inside track on government contracts to large campaign contributors or those who bailed the president out of one of his many failed enterprises. And Halliburton, the company that employed Vice President Cheney as CEO and later awarded him an overly generous severance package despite his poor performance, was permitted to forgo the bidding process entirely.
However, with America having lost nearly 3 million jobs and the economy trying to struggle out of a recession, it might be a good time to try “corporate” affirmative action. This would allow the government to give weight to an assortment of factors when awarding government contracts other than the fact that a company donated millions to political campaigns.
The way the system would work is that contracts would be awarded to the lowest effective bid. The effective bid would be the actual bid minus 1 percent for each business policy embraced by the bidder that are positive for the U.S. economy and American workers and by adding 1 percent for each factor that is detrimental.
Say for instance two companies were bidding for a contract. Company A’s actual bid was $2 billion and Company B’s was $1.9 billion.
Company A manufactures its products predominantly in the U.S. It provides employees a comprehensive health plan. And within the last five years, it has made capital improvements to clean up polluting plants. These three factors would allow it to reduce its bid by 3 percent, for an effective bid of $1.94 billion.
Company B employs foreign workers at substandard wages. Accounting, payroll and other backroom operations have been out-sourced to foreign entities. Earnings within the last five years were restated due to accounting irregularities. Executives or board members have received lucrative compensation packages despite poor corporate results. And the company has an offshore address to avoid U.S. taxes. These five negative factors would result in a 5 percent increase to its actual bid for an effective bid of $1.995 billion.
Company A would be awarded the contract. And even though the contract would cost Americans an additional $100 million, it would stimulate our economy, rather than China’s. It is also likely that the entire $100 million difference would be returned in the form of corporate and income taxes. More importantly, corporate affirmative action would encourage broad social value by supporting minority companies.
By minority companies I mean those corporations that put the interests of Americans ahead of their own greed. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. His compensation package is directly linked to his performance. Comments can be restated to:).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 3, 2004. Read the original PDF.