By IN YOUR SPACE BY CHRISTINA S. PORTER
Being a Landlord in today’s office market has been more of a struggle than some signed on for. The tech boom of the fabulous ’90s is behind us and the post Sept. 11 recession is gone. The economy is gaining steam.
After the flamboyant spending of the dotcom era, landlords have learned many lessons and one of the more important ones is the advantage of having a letter of credit, as opposed to a cash security deposit as an instrument of lease securiti-zation. This is especially important when a tenant bankruptcy comes into play.
From a bankruptcy court’s standpoint, a cash security deposit is considered property of the debtor’s bankruptcy estate — making it the responsibility of the landlord to obtain a court order to use the cash security deposit. On the other hand, courts view letters of credit as enforceable third party agreements between landlords beneficiary and the issuing bank, not as property of the tenant’s bankruptcy estate. A tenants’ collateral may be subject to the jurisdiction of the bankruptcy courts, but the issuer of the credit assumes that risk, not the landlord.
Even though a letter of credit is preferable to a cash security deposit, it is not a cure all. Banks follow the terms and conditions set forth in the letter of credit very strictly. It’s important that they are drawn precisely in that obtaining the funds provided in a letter of credit can also be time consuming. One suggestion is to not make obtaining the funds contingent on any event or circumstance, dependent on any third party’s control and make sure that there are precise instructions given to the issuer as to when to disburse funds or “draws.” A letter of credit should state that a “draw” can be made if the beneficiary delivers the original letter of credit and, at most, a note from the beneficiary stating that the tenant is in default of the lease. It should not require that the tenant acknowledge the default occurred or that it received a written notice of such default.
It is important to know that a letter of credit is a “negotiable instrument,” meaning that if the original is lost or stolen the issuing bank will not replace it. Each letter of credit is unique to each beneficiary. Banks have strict assignment rules and will usually charge a transfer or reis-suance fee. A landlord might want to make it a condition of the letter of credit that there be no transfer or reissuance fee, especially if there is a possibility it may sell the building.
A bank that has a local branch as the issuer of the letter of credit is important. Dealing face to face with a banker is sure to facilitate a draw on a letter of credit. However, it is not uncommon for an out of state or non-domestic bank to be “confirmed” by a local bank. This confirmation is reflected in an additional document from the confirming bank and basically amounts to a promise from the confirming bank to honor the letter of credit if the issuer does not do so.
Most letters of credit are for a term of one year and automatically renew annually. If there is a nonrenewal clause — many times there is — be sure to thoroughly understand the conditions upon which the letter of credit does not automatically renew. There are creative ways to use letters of credit, especially in relation to a lease requiring landlord financed tenant improvements. Finally, as with all legal issues, a consultation with expert legal counsel prior to constructing a letter of credit to insure you have the most up to date and accurate information is essential.
Some leases may include the letter of credit in the “damages cap” imposed by a bankruptcy court. Be sure to add the language that the letter of credit is “in lieu of” a security deposit. Of course nothing is guaranteed but this type of language could give a building owner a better chance on recouping any losses from a tenant bankruptcy sooner than later. (Christina S. Porter is in the business of selling and leasing office and industrial buildings she (310) 806-6104, or e-mail).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 20, 2004. Read the original PDF.