LETTERS
By John Lord Santa Monica
The Daily Press’ early coverage of the school donations issue implied that this is a new problem. It is not. As I recall, back in the ’60s or ’70s, the school board transferred to Edison Elementary a greenhouse that had been donated to Franklin Elementary. At the time, as a parent I was outraged, but eventually I have come to see the wisdom and even necessity of such actions. As to the legality of transfers, I believe individual public schools are not legal entities that can receive charitable donations. The gift is made to the district, which, unless it has agreed to any restrictions that came with the gift, can do whatever it pleases with it. Various attempts to get around this by, for example, having a foundation pay the salaries of staff — having teachers in a public school who are not employees of the district — have been rebuffed in the courts.
There are no First Amendment issues in our current problem because no restriction on the raising of money has been proposed, only in the manner in which the district LETTERS, from page 6 would accept it.
As long as we have neighborhood elementary schools — and let’s hope we always do — schools will reflect the character of the neighborhood. One has only to open the newspaper to the real estate section and compare the prices of houses near Franklin and Edison to realize that, other things being equal, Franklin will naturally have an easier time raising donations than Edison. And other things aren’t equal. I would bet that Edison and McKinley have a greater proportion of working mothers than Franklin. And women, particularly well-educated women with some free time during the day, are the powerhouse behind school fundraising.
The other thing you will notice in those real estate ads is realtors touting Franklin. During the 1970s I was privileged to observe classes at Franklin. The teachers were excellent, and the faculty as a whole was outstanding. I also had a chance to do some observing at Edison, and, in my opinion, the faculty was every bit as good as Franklin’s. That was decades ago, and the neighborhoods and schools have changed, but Edison’s teachers, I suspect, are not getting the credit they deserve from the larg-er community. Reality and reputation among realtors and home buyers differ. We do not have a problem now, but we could have. Expenditures per pupil is right up there with the socioeconomic class of the student body and the ability of the principal as a correlate with the knowledge and skills with which students graduate. If we allow some schools to spend much more money per pupil than others, we will eventually end up with a district that actually does, briefly, contain a few strong schools and a bunch of weak ones.
Such a situation is inherently unstable and creates many management problems, notably in the recruitment and retention of staff. As teachers acquire experience and seniority, they often transfer to the star school. New hires, often inexperienced, are posted to the weak schools. Then the whole district is hit as potential hires who are experienced, highly-qualified teachers, do not want to run the risk of assignment to a school full of poorly prepared students, and accept offers from other districts. Eventually the excellent school runs out of good teachers and is no longer so good. Furthermore, personnel from the weaker schools, which are likely to tolerate a lower level of competence, can migrate into district administration roles, where they weaken the whole system. Turkeys hire turkeys. It is not only a matter of equity. If you want a good public school for your children, you need a good district.
Some parents seem to have confused public schools with private schools. But a school district is not in essence simply a bunch of private schools grouped together for administrative convenience. Some of its moral and legal duties, and responsibilities are very different from those of a private school. It must maintain a reasonable parity in what it offers its students. Hence Superintendent Deasy’s proposal. Some clear policy everyone is aware of is needed.
At the same time, I have to say the “tax” proposal strikes me as more than a little bizarre, particularly in its regressive nature. A multi-million dollar donation to one school could, ironically, prove a real problem to the district if the board’s hands would be tied by formal adoption of this “tax” policy.
It would seem more sensible to exempt smaller donations (in order to encourage parental and community gifts and to avoid a bookkeeping nightmare). Exempt receipts from one annual fundraising event per school (because these are largely conversions of volunteer time into cash and parents mainly volunteer for their own school, and because these events are a significant part of the life of the school). By “fundraising event,” I mean an event like Franklin’s Halloween Carnival, not a simple solicitation of funds. Spread larger donations (say, a total annual contribution from one donor/family of over $20,000, including corporate matching funds) so that the designated school received, say, twice as much money from the donation than any other school in the district did, on a pupil population basis, but every school of that type (elementary school; middle school, etc.) received some benefit from the donation. The proportion could even vary with the size of total donations to that school that year, but it should always be high enough to not destroy the volunteers’ incentive. Some universities use a similar system in allocating part of the overhead from grant money among all members of a department, partly as a way of reducing friction between faculty members.
Over the years, volunteers at some SMMUSD schools have acquired some pretty highly-developed fund-raising skills. A letter to the editor last week suggested they teach these to volunteers in other schools. This is a praiseworthy suggestion, and if it is carried out and succeeds, it will go a long way toward defusing the issue. First they have to find suitable volunteers. In the meantime, the school board is left with the problem of preventing a great disparity in per pupil expenditures among its schools. No doubt the budget problems of the state and local governments are putting many valuable school programs — music comes immediately to mind — in mortal danger. But a district is a district; we are all in this together. Or, if the problem truly centers around the Malibu schools’ commendable success in fundraising, perhaps they would be more comfortable, and better off, as a separate district.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 26, 2004. Read the original PDF.