By TED WINTERER
If your beach reading included light fare such as “Moby Dick” and “Tristam Shandy” and you’re ready for a tome of greater heft, you might enjoy City Hall’s new “Opportunities and Challenges” report. Running about 400 pages, it’s the second such lengthy document produced by the city’s multi-year process for revising the blueprints for land use and transportation in Santa Monica for the next 20 years.
The first report coalesced public input on our future into “Emerging Themes,” such as “Santa Monica’s growth should be modest” to keep it a “community built at an appropriate town scale.” The new document’s purpose is to examine ways in which these goals can be attained through the update to the city’s General Plan.
“Opportunities and Challenges” is quite comprehensive and thoughtful and includes many fine notions for improvements to our town. However, it’s not without its flaws.
Foremost is its assertion that the community believes that “(e)xisting height limits should be maintained.” I think otherwise: what people want perpetuated is existing heights, not the current zoning ceiling which might allow a block of two story buildings to be rebuilt to four floors. No one at any public meetings reviewed a model of our city built out to the maximum densities presently allowed. Instead, what folks like is the scale of Santa Monica today.
Then while the report is purportedly objective, there’s an inherent bias, despite the public’s expressed goals, in favor of population growth of at least 10 percent and a corresponding increase in density in certain neighborhoods. The authors encourage redevelopment along commercial corridors such as Wilshire and Lincoln, within the industrial zone surrounding Olympic and adjacent to the proposed light rail running through Bergamot Station to downtown. This “Smart Growth” would consist of taller, mixed-use buildings (apartments above retail) along bus and rail lines. The theory is that new residents will take public transit to work, walk to local services and not further congest our streets with autos.
It sounds swell, but I think there are reasons to be skeptical about some of these assumptions: 1. Until the city can produce a study proving that denser, transit-oriented growth will actually increase ridership on trains and busses, current trends suggests otherwise. Jammed freeways and high gas prices have yet to cause people to switch to mass transit. 2. Given that past transit planning in LA County has been driven by politics rather than common sense (such as the decision to end the Green Line short of LAX to appease cab drivers), there’s no guarantee the Expo light rail will run into Santa Monica. Even now LA Councilman Bill Rosendahl is talking about routing it to Venice instead. So while it might make sense to develop along rapid bus lines, why build for light rail until it’s a sure thing? 3. Mixed-use development has failed thus far in places such as Sixth Street downtown to provide the mix of uses which might obviate the need for car trips. 4. It’s perhaps no accident the report promotes growth largely in the city’s Northridge earthquake redevelopment zone, areas in which City Hall would profit handsomely from increased property taxes. We need to make sure fiscal policy isn’t driving land use policy, as it did in the decision to allow expansion of auto dealerships to the detriment of neighbors while implicitly promoting driving over mass transit. 5. Smart Growth is a nifty phrase with some laudable tenets, but we have to be cautious that it’s not being hijacked by those with a vested interest in development, in the same way George W. has co-opted “Clear Skies” and “Healthy Forests” as a cover for environmental degradation.
I agree that we should promote alternate modes of transportation and that sectors of our commercial corridors would benefit from a makeover — wouldn’t it be nice if Lincoln south of the freeway was pedestrian friendly and neighborhood serving? But let’s plan for small-scale redevelopment that furthers walkability, not for tall buildings serving as an economic engine and justified by unproved planning theory.
Finally, the report observes that our population has been stable over the last 25 years while office space has increased 170 percent, creating a jobs/housing imbalance which clogs our streets. So why would we build any more offices?
It’s perhaps prudent to look at our town as an ecosystem with an inherent carrying capacity before we are driven to race like lemmings into the sea. The opportunity before us is to keep our city livable and sustainable. The challenge will be to curtail the forces within and without City Hall which favor more growth than our citizens desire. (Ted Winterer)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 2, 2005. Read the original PDF.