HIP TO BE SQUARE
By CAROLINE BODKIN
My apartment was on the third floor of a four-story, 80-year-old building. I loved it because it was old. I loved the rooftops, I loved the glass door handles and high ceilings, but mostly I loved it because it was mine. For my first two years on my own, after college, it was my place in the world.
It was me. It wasn’t paid for by my parents, I didn’t share it with a roommate, I knew its corners and conditions, I came and went as I pleased, it held my clothes and my photos of old friends and the paintings my grandmother painted before she passed away. When other things were in question, when I only knew four people in this city, before I'd ever been in love, when I was unsure about most everything, I knew at least I had one place to return to for peace even when I did not feel peaceful.
Of all the people who lived and changed and cried and made love there, for two years, it was just for me.
But for a while, towards the end of those two years, I was notably absent from my place. It changed after I fell in love. Instead of coming and going home to and from my place, I came and went to him in his (which is larger, more comfortable for two, and has available parking).
Life moved forward in this way: Once my place was enough for “me” as there was “just me,” and then “just me” started turning into “me and him,” and the place that fit just “me” became too small for “we.”
We started talking about moving in together. I imagined what that would look like, my photos and my plants and the paintings my grandmother painted before she passed away all living together with his things, and truly, it made me happy. My place in the world becoming ours. My place in the world being next to someone else, regardless of where. My life's course with company.
Some people make a decision like this with very little thought. I heard a story about a guy who came here to visit the girl he'd been dating for one month, missed his plane on the way out, and so stayed with her and never left (until they broke up...).
For better or worse, I was not that person and neither was my boyfriend. No. We are deliberators. We debated back and forth about the pros and cons, came up with various scenarios where we lived in one part of town or another, would work near or far from home, share one big one bedroom or try to find a two bedroom that was affordable. We wondered if we'd argue over the remote control. We talked around a lot. Each of our places in the world was changing into something we couldn’t fully see and that was scary.
Life pushes for change. Had you not given up your place in your parent's home, you never would have found your place at school — and unless you gave up that place, you would never have found your own third-story apartment, and unless I left my place, the current tenant would have had nowhere to go.
I turned it over and over in my head. I deliberated with him and by myself, sought counsel from friends. And then I remembered something that was different about this change: Where it once was just me, it had become we.
And we had outgrown the places that were made to fit only one.
The person I had become did not fit into a place that was home only to myself.
There have been many times in my life when, while searching for a place, I felt out of place. My first day of junior high, Friday nights with sorority girls, the streets in Saigon, my old job — they all showed me my place in the world by making me feel uneasy.
But never once have I felt out of place with him.
And where we went, we arrived together, and that place has become ours. (Caroline Bodkin lived and still lives in LA. You can ).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 12, 2004. Read the original PDF.