Skip to content

Live by the sword, you will die by the sword

Published:

By THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

Is Sen. John Kerry running for Swift Boat Commander or President of the United States of America? If it’s the latter, then he had best stop talking about the past. Presidential campaigns are about the future, and Kerry is letting this campaign slip past him because he can’t seem to leave the past behind.

There are three separate, yet converging dynamics occurring in this race, and Kerry is being out foxed in each dimension.

Incumbents have a lower bar to clear than do challengers. They don’t have to defend their biography because by virtue of being in office, they’re imbued with the legitimacy of that office — unless a scandal has revealed that their character was not what the voters believed it to be when they voted for them. Incumbents need only to: (a) defend his or her performance, and (b) propose an agenda for future. Neither is difficult in a system like ours, where shared powers, overlapping jurisdictions, and competing interests make spreading the blame for mistakes and taking credit for successes relatively simple.

Challengers must not only propose an agenda for the future, but they must also pass a credibility test with the electorate. They must defend their biography — their character and their performance over the course of their entire life — along with their plans. It’s more like clearing two hurdles instead of one high bar.

Timing matters. If a politician discovers that his constituents want more recreational space, and proposes a bill for more national park land, he’s called “an environmental leader.” If he reads the newspaper, which shows that people in his district favor more recreational space by a 2- 1 margin, and he signs onto national park legislation, he’s referred to as “a poll-watcher.”

Whether a politician is seen as leading or following trends, or acting defensively or offensively, matters to both the voters and the media.

If you look closely at most polls, Kerry leads Bush by about 10 percentage points (60 percent to 40 percent, outside the typical margin of error, which is usually +/- 3.5 percent) on questions related to the economy, health care and education.

On questions related to terrorism, Bush tends to edge out Kerry, though mostly they are tied (within the margin of error, both around 45 percent). On questions related to Iraq, Kerry and Bush go back and forth with the lead, though mostly they are tied — within the margin of error, again around 45 percent.

This has been a fairly stable dynamic since about May, which leaves only one question: If you have a significant advantage on the economy, health care and education (issues that your opponent has a poor record on), why would you not choose to take this fight to him? Why would anyone continue to do battle on a turf on which they held no advantage?

One rule that is as true in politics as it is in sports, if you play your opponent’s game, you’ll lose.

For Kerry to win, he needs to repeat (again and again): “Mr. President, why have you not stewarded our economy, our health care system, and our education system better? I understand you’ve been fighting terrorism, protecting the American people, and waging a battle in Iraq, but as my vice presidential nominee once said: ‘A president must be able to walk and chew gum at the same time,’ and you, Mr. Bush, do not seem to be able to do that. I think I could do better. My biography shows I can. But more importantly, here’s what I would do if I were in your shoes (a), (b), (c) …”

Instead, Kerry has not moved on from the attacks on his service record. The campaign’s message seems to be: “When I was in Vietnam.”

Kerry should have used these last three weeks (in between the Democratic Convention and the Republican Convention), to propose his agenda for the future. He should have forced Bush onto his turf, so that he would have had to defend himself during his own convention.

Kerry had the opportunity to have the GOP playing his game in New York. But by conceding this time to “biography clarification,” Kerry conceded that he’s willing to play defense up until Election Day. Kerry now has to wait to respond to the Republicans’ newly proposed agenda until after their convention, and this means that by Labor Day it will all just look like “me, too” to most voters.

Here’s The Thing: Kerry didn’t accomplish what he needed to do this summer — put Bush on the defensive. Kerry sought to do it with his biography of military service and his record on foreign policy, but the “close-up” on those numbers tell you that was not the turf to fight the battle on. But Karl Rove already knew that. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester in Arkansas, at Hendrix College and UALR. She).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 27, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe