By Tony Street Bend, Ore.
I am 100 percent against rent control but if the citizens of Santa Monica want it so badly let’s at least make sure that it is used for its intended purpose — to keep low-moderate income people living in Santa Monica.
Both landlords and council members agree on one thing — rent control as it exists is not a perfect system. Landlords claim that well-off tenants are taking advantage of their status and councilpersons like Feinstein and Genser, among others, feel it is better to have a broken system than no system at all. (“Broken” meaning the landlords get screwed).
Excuse me for saying this for the umpteenth time, but why isn’t it mandatory for all rent-controlled tenants to be means tested? I’ve actually asked the Rent Control Board this question and the man’s response was, “The law wasn’t written that way.” Sure, there will still be some who will hide their true incomes, but at least they will have to chance acting “illegally” if it is a law to hand over your 1040s each year in order to remain a tenant. The threat of incarceration should help to make people be honest.
Having a family member who is in the mortgage business in Santa Monica for years, I can tell you that the landlords are not wrong with their contention that many people who live in rent controlled apartments are actually well off. My family member would tell me of “bartenders” who made $80,000 a year who lived in rent controlled apartments and were looking to buy property in Southern California.
I lived in a complex where a young couple was telling me that they were looking into buying a vacation condo in Hawaii. When I asked them how they could afford it, they told me that the $500 they were paying for rent was such a small percentage of their income that they had saved enough to start looking. I followed up by asking if they were going to give up their apartment and they said, “Are you kidding? We will never give up this place. We’ll come here to vacation.”
As far as councilman Genser’s assertion that census data shows that it is a “myth” that Bentley-driving, rent controlled living tenants exist in Santa Monica, well maybe not Bentleys but definitely BMWs.
Don’t take my word for it. Look at SMDP articles on the Beverly Hills lawyer who kept his oceanfront, rent control apartments while living in his Beverly Hills mansion.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 17, 2004. Read the original PDF.