Skip to content

Living through the pain inflicted by City Hall requires patience and time

Published:

By TED WINTERER

I’ve been writing this column for more than six months and often people, particularly my loved ones who suffer from my reduced attentions, ask, “Why?”

Now it’s time to divulge my dirty little secret. I want to rag about a parking ticket.

I was born in Brooklyn and lived for 28 years in New York City, which pretty much explains the surliness that is the trademark of these writings. And if you think the average New Yorker is rude, try dealing with the city bureaucracy in the Big Apple. You could spend days getting brusquely shuttled from one department to another until, crushed by the weight of the bloated municipal government, the only recourse was to surrender.

So I was delighted when, soon after moving to Santa Monica 14 years ago, I chose to contest a parking ticket. I sauntered down to City Hall where my concerns were immediately addressed by a smiling, cordial city staffer. I stated my case and in short order my ticket was expunged. I thought, “I’m going to like living here.”

Then last October I decided to challenge a $35 ticket. Thus began my ordeal, as I discovered you can no longer dispute these things over the counter. Instead, you must endure a byzantine process that could break the hardiest individual.

First, you have to go to the new police headquarters, fill out a lengthy form and cite the reasons your ticket isn’t deserved. Then you wait.

If you’re lucky — and I was — you get a letter granting a hearing. You have to pay the fine, as you are deemed guilty until proven innocent. You then choose from a selection of inconvenient times and locations for your hearing, such as Tuesday mornings in Beverly Hills. I chose Wednesday evening in Santa Monica as it was the only sane option. I mailed in my request and payment and was notified I had a hearing scheduled for Jan. 12 at 6:45 p.m., three months after the alleged parking violation.

On Jan. 12, the heavens opened up.

Roads through the Hollywood Hills closed, the freeways were awash with water, and traffic everywhere in the county came to a standstill. Battling the deluge, I got to the hearing location at 6:50 p.m., at which point the hearing officer told me I would have to reschedule, as I was his last appointment and he wanted to go to dinner.

I called the next day to reschedule and was told I couldn’t. How could that be? The hearing officer had advised me to do so.

I then sent a flurry of e-mails to city officials whining about my predicament and eventually got a new hearing on Feb. 16. I presented my case and in about five minutes was told I was no longer liable for the ticket, which left me wondering why the hearing officer couldn’t have delayed his supper the prior month.

A couple of days later I got another parking ticket, a $47 violation I richly deserved. Soon after I received by mail official notice of my victory at my hearing: I could choose a refund of my $35 or apply it to an unpaid citation. So I opted to use the credit and sent the form back with $12 to cover the rest of my new ticket.

The next day an unsolicited refund check for $35 for the first infraction showed up in my mailbox, followed by a letter demanding the remaining $35 due on my new citation. Rather than endure any more of this torture, I paid off the new ticket and cashed the refund for the old violation. I then calculated that my time expended on the matter had netted me about 35 cents per hour and resisted the urge to weep.

Is there a lesson to be learned from the reams of paperwork and the city employee hours required to drag out this process? Clearly, I’ll be less inclined to contest any future transgression.

But what really troubles me is how in the last decade City Hall has grown so large and bureaucratic. With only a few exceptions, city officials are affable, helpful and well-intended. However, their collective mass has become so bulky that a once nimble and responsive government is now lumbering and oafish. When it steps on your toes, it really hurts. (Ted Winterer is a writer who lives in Ocean Park. He’s now more vigilant about where he parks and)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 8, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe