By Tom Larmore
(Editor’s note: This is the first installment of a weekly column about the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed the ordinance last July, which requires businesses that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees $12.25 an hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance — which is before voters this November — to be rescinded.) Once upon a time, in a mythical land known by its inhabitants simply as “Here,” apples sold for prices ranging from $1 to $2, depending upon quality. Then an influx of apple imports from the neighboring land known by Hereites as “There” cut apple prices in half leading to an increased consumption of apples but devastating the financial position of Here apple growers.
The growers, wanting to raise the price of apples, banded together to elect a pro-apple majority in the local council. Following a successful campaign, the growers prevailed on the new Here government to pass a law mandating a minimum price of $2 for apples. Once the law went into effect, several rather predicable things happened.
Apple growers from Here, There and everywhere began flooding the Here market with apples because the price on the world market ranged from 50 cents to $1, as it had in Here prior to the new minimum apple price law. Naturally, this expansion in the supply of apples would, under free market conditions, drive down the price of apples even further causing consumers to buy more apples, switching allegiance from oranges until their price also declined.
At the controlled apple price, however, consumers began buying fewer apples and more oranges. In fact, at $2 only the highest quality apples were purchased by those still willing to pay the artificially high price. As a result, millions of lower-grade apples were wasted until the market adjusted to the new price. When equilibrium returned, the demand for apples in Here had greatly diminished and was limited to only those of the highest quality. Lower grade apples were shipped to lands outside of Here where they were sold for less or converted into less desirable uses, such as juice and apple sauce.
Substitute labor for apples and employers for apple consumers in this story and you will understand one of the many reasons why I believe the ordinance creating minimum wage requirements adopted by the council last year represents bad policy. By mandating an 80 percent increase in the minimum wage, I believe it will prove to be counterpro-ductive from the perspective of those who support it by harming rather than helping low-income workers.
I plan to write a weekly series of short articles on this law over the next few months until the Nov. 5 election to explain the ordinance and the many reasons I believe it will adversely affect most low-income workers, many employers and all residents.
Please stay with me as this important issue heats up. Better yet, if you disagree, write in and explain why you think I’m wrong — the dialogue, unlike the law, will benefit the voters. (Tom Larmore is a property rights attorney and a Santa Monica resident.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 5, 2002. Read the original PDF.