Skip to content

Living wage full of unintended consequences

Published:

By Tom Larmore

(Editor’s note: This is one of a series of weekly columns editorializing on the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees $12.25 an hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance to be rescinded, which is before voters this November.)

One of the inherent risks in any legislative action is to avoid introducing incentives that run contrary to the original intent. While many of the proponents of the City’s Minimum Wage Ordinance have laudable motives, good intentions do not necessarily make good laws. Part of the legislative process is to craft laws which introduce the right incentives while regulating conduct thought to have negative social implications. For a variety of reasons, the City Council failed this fundamental test.

One of the major flaws in the ordinance is the fact that it will discourage employers from providing health insurance, thereby potentially contributing to one of society’s primary problems.

The ordinance, now Proposition JJ, defines “Health Benefits” to be: “A payment towards the provision of health care benefits for employees and their dependents in the amount of $1.75 per hour [during the first year]...” The required “Minimum Wage” is an hourly wage of either $10.50 per hour with Health Benefits or $12.25 per hour without Health Benefits.” (The health benefit threshold goes to $2.50 after one year and both amounts increase annually based upon changes in the Consumer Price Index.)

The amount contributed by an employer toward health benefits for any particular employee depends on the nature of the health plan, the employee’s age and the number of dependents covered, with the lowest rate being for a young, single worker.

The perversity of this scheme results from the fact that the employer gets no credit against the $12.25 minimum wage unless at least $1.75 per hour is spent for health benefits. But no more than $1.75 is permitted irrespective of the amount actually contributed. Depending upon the nature of the plan, the cost for health coverage for a young, single worker may well be significantly less than $1.75 per hour. (First beginning at $295 per month, and then increasing to $433 when the required threshold benefit goes to $2.50 per hour.) As a result, the employer is forced to pay the full $12.25 minimum wage for this employee as if no health insurance were provided at all, thereby incentivizing the employer to drop health coverage for this employee.

On the other hand, if health coverage for a particular employee costs more than $1.75 per hour, as it might with an older worker with a family, the employer receives no more than $1.75 credit against the mandatory minimum wage. As a result, the employer is given a financial reason to drop health coverage for these workers and pay the maximum $12.25 per hour wage.

Therefore, the employer is motivated to at least consider dropping health coverage altogether because the cost for some employees will be less than $1.75, meaning that absolutely no credit is given against the $12.25 wage, while the cost for others will be more than $1.75 even though only the credit is limited to $1.75.

The employer cannot really escape this result. If coverage is enhanced in order to place the young, single employees at or above the $1.75 threshold, then the employer’s cost for family workers will increase as well. Similarly, if coverage is reduced in order to bring down the cost for workers with families, coverage for young, single workers will also be reduced. The only way out of this dilemma would be to allow a greater credit against the minimum wage in order to give the employers an incentive to pay for dependent coverage, if they are not already doing so, or increase the nature of the benefits. However, the ordinance does not permit this rather logical solution.

The result is that the employer’s incentive, at least with respect to the ordinance, is exactly opposite from what would represent good social policy.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 3, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe