By Todd Flora Evelyn Jerome
Editor’s note: The following is the debut of “Think Twice,” a weekly column with opposing viewpoints on the same issue from two friends who don’t always agree in their politics. Evelyn Jerome, a four-year resident of Santa Monica and Todd Flora, a five-year resident, carry on the same types of conversations many would hear at the local watering hole or coffee shop. Flora and Jerome, both Southern California natives and Democrats — one perhaps more conservative than the other — plan to present their opinions on both sides of issues in the city, the state and the nation. THINK ■The Living Wage movement must continue in Santa Monica, and it must succeed.
A $5 million gross receipt threshold was put in Measure JJ, as was a hardship exemption for businesses “on the bubble.” Over 100 economists endorsed the living wage, as they know that in nearly 90 cities around the nation, living wages decreased poverty without damaging business.
And still the ideologues fought against a measure that would have resulted in greater employee loyalty, and therefore less absenteeism, less attrition, and lower training costs.
They masked their more honest ideological arguments through deceptive mailers stating the living wage was a threat to everything from schools to libraries to women's reproductive choice. You must be kidding.
I'm pro profit — but I'm not pro windfall profit at the expense of investing in workers, the best “capital, plant, and equipment” investment a service industry business can make. I further reject old fashioned business ideology that says “the market this, and that market that,” when it isn't the market that may or may not be inviting a reform like the living wage, but merely conservative ideological blinders that are actively preventing it. Some wealthier employers - not all - simply cannot imagine a world where workers are paid enough to feed their families and get off of the public dole (saving our tax dollars). That's fine. But have the guts to admit it.
While focused on economic justice, the living wage issue here is also about the kind of city Santa Monica chooses to be. Ask yourself - if you only had two choices, would you want this City to: A) keep its commitment to largely progressive values, with an agenda that for the last two decades had made Santa Monica an enviable tourist destination and first choice place to live and work? Or, B) would you want this city controlled by a vocal minority of conservative leaders who would run roughshod over renter protections, workers, coastal protection, and allow for “monster mansions” to replace the homes that created the Santa Monica aesthetic?
Some may think my question is loaded. But this is exactly the choice we face. The living wage is an extension of this larger question. I hope your choice is “A.” ■ Local control. States’ rights. Progressives fight against these principles that offer policy flexibility based on “community standards” because of the disparity that results.
“Local control” has allowed some states to implement a 24-hour waiting period before women can obtain an abortion, and has allowed some school districts to teach creationism as a factual alternative to evolution.
Progressives hate local control. But what does this have to do with the living wage?
Why is differential policy wrong for some issues but not others?
All American citizens should have the same rights regardless of where they live. As for the issue of wages, I support a stepped-up increase in California’s minimum wage.
But the recent Santa Monica living wage campaign was a deliberately dishonest one.
Why fabricate a “coastal zone” around four blocks, designing the ordinance to affect only a handful of businesses? Why not just come out and say this wage shall apply to these hotels? Are workers who work west of Fourth Street worth more than those who work in Santa Monica but east of it?
Why hide behind the fact that the Santa Monica proposal was radically different from every other living wage ordinance ever passed? Eighty other cities in the country have a living wage, but those ordinances apply ONLY to businesses seeking contracts with municipal entities. Those municipalities have said, “if you provide a product or service, for which you will be compensated with taxpayer dollars, you must pay this particular wage.” Apples and oranges.
Who decides how much profit is “too much” for private business? Government? The unions? Living wage activists talk about “windfall profits” and “social responsibility.” We argue against government legislating morality, then turn around and ask the voters to mandate “social responsibility.” Not consistent, not fair.
As to the argument that people need a living wage to feed their families (or “to put food on their family,” as our President said), I was taught that you do better by advancing your skills. What value do you bring to an employer? Get a degree – high school, college or higher – earn more. Learn a new skill, get a raise. Cause and effect. We cannot legislate what some businesses in some areas pay some of their workers.
And for those who reject all of the above, just go back to your “community standards” argument. The community voted.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 24, 2002. Read the original PDF.