Skip to content

Living wage supporters want to have it both ways

Published:

By Guest Commentary By Naia Sheffield

(Editor’s note: This is one of a series of weekly columns editorializing on the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses in the coastal zone that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees up to $12.25 an hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance to be rescinded, which is before voters this November.

The Daily Press has asked organizers of Santa Monicans Allied for Responsible Tourism, which supports the living wage, to provide a counter-point opinion to balance out the debate. Those organizers said they will provide commentary, but have not yet done so. Other supporters of the living wage measure have not come forward to express their opposing viewpoints, which the Daily Press welcomes.) Here’s a quandary for you. Suppose you support the city’s minimum wage ordinance — Proposition JJ — because you believe it will benefit low-wage workers in Santa Monica. However, opponents of JJ, like me, contend that the measure will result in a loss of job opportunities for those same workers, thereby hurting the very people it is designed to help. While you would like to dispute my position, you have no basis for doing so; in fact, almost all the relevant research points in my direction.

Then one day an acknowledged expert in the field of labor economics publishes a study he conducted on the effects of typical “living wage” laws. This study concludes that such laws raise the income for some workers, result in job losses for others and, on balance, seem to benefit more workers than they hurt, thereby having a moderately positive effect on urban poverty. Because the study is the first to assess the impact of these laws, it gains a great deal of media attention.

While the study isn’t perfect from your perspective because Proposition JJ is very different from any of the laws which were analyzed, you decide to use it as support in your campaign. In fact, you go so far as to cite the study in your ballot argument.

Then the expert comes to town and explains why his study has no bearing on Proposition JJ (primarily because of the massive differences between JJ and typical “living wage” laws, as discussed in earlier columns). Moreover, he says that Proposition JJ is not a wise policy for those seeking to increase the income of low-wage workers. What do you do now?

This is exactly the position in which JJ’s supporters found themselves following the recent Chamber of Commerce luncheon when one of the speakers was Dr. David Neumark, a widely respected labor economist. Their solution to the problem was ironic, indeed.

After having used Dr. Neumark’s study to support their position in the ballot argument (and probably intending to use it in future mail pieces and other campaign statements), they attacked the chamber for inviting him because he was an opponent of JJ!

Remarkably two-faced. Evaluating Proposition JJ requires keeping two important distinctions in mind.

First, it is critical to separate the laudable goal of helping low-wage workers and their families from the actual results of the measure — good intentions do not necessarily make good laws.

Second is the difference between JJ and typical living wage laws, the kind studied by Dr. Neumark. Those laws are limited to employers entering into service contracts with the city and, in some cases, companies receiving direct financial assistance from the city, such as tax incentives. Because JJ covers private businesses having no direct economic contact with the city (other than the obligation to pay taxes), its effects will be totally different. It was this message that Dr. Neumark was trying to convey.

While advocates of JJ were busy characterizing Dr. Neumark as an opponent of JJ, they conveniently neglected to mention that they were using his totally irrelevant study as support for their own position.

Which is it guys? (Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a local property rights attorney.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 10, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe