Skip to content

Lobbyists are paying for travel: Who cares?

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

It’s been an exciting few weeks on the congressional scandal front. Lobbyist Jack Abramoff appears to have paid for travel to the Northern Mariana Islands for not only Majority Leader Tom Delay (R- Tex.), but also for Reps. James Clyburn (D-SC.) and Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.). Speaker Dennis Hastert (R-Ill.) got the Republican conference to help repeal the ethics reforms they passed four months ago (it wasn’t a flip-flop, really). The House Ethics Committee met and decided to review Delay’s questionable activities. Two members of the Ethics Committee (Reps. Lamar Smith of Texas and Tom Cole of Oklahoma) recused themselves from all matters that deal with Delay because both have contributed to his legal defense fund.

The public response is not surprising. A recent CNN/Gallup/USA Today public opinion poll shows that “82 percent believe lobbyist-funded trips are a serious ethical matter;” 46 percent say “very serious” and 36 percent say “moderately serious.” Former Rep. Lee Hamilton (D-Ind.) suggested that there is only way around this: Ban all privately funded trips. Hamilton was not suggesting that congressional members stop traveling. He was only proposing that private entities stop paying. He wants government to pay for it. He also wants members to have to disclose their itineraries.

With all this activity, I decided to conduct my own focus group — with my introduction to American government class. I e-mailed them a copy of Hamilton’s proposal, told them to look into the issues facing Majority Leader Tom Delay, and finish reading the chapter on interest groups. Tuesday I asked my students: ■ Would Hamilton’s proposal work? ■ Would it alter special interest influence in any meaningful way? ■ Should the public pay for congressional travel? ■ How much are you willing to allocate to each member for it? ß Should members travel, at all? Before reporting what they said, a bit about the demographics of this class. There are 43 students in the class (most days about 38 show up) and it is a general education requirement, which means that the class contains students from every grade level (freshman to graduating senior).

On the first day of class, I administered a “politics and you” survey to get a sense of where the students are in terms of political knowledge, interest, partisanship, and ideology. This class is about average in terms of interest and knowledge — over one quarter would like to understand how the Electoral College actually works, even though 80 percent voted in the 2004 presidential election). This class — unlike others I have taught — is evenly split between Republicans and Democrats (there are a few independents), and liberals and conservatives. Though after having taught them now for almost a full semester, it is clear that the majority tend to possess libertarian beliefs. “Live and let live” would sum up many of their governing philosophy.

So, when I asked about Hamilton’s proposal, the response was fairly uniform. They didn’t want to pay more for government. And they weren’t altogether sure how valuable congressional travel really was, but most felt that if members were going to do it then “special interests might as well pay.” Their reasoning seemed to be that special interests pay for everything else, including campaigns, so why should this be any different?

When I asked if they believed that by making the public pay for travel, they might make elected officials more responsive to the public and less responsive to special interests? They said: “Yeah, but it isn’t like that would make much of a difference. There is always someone who wants something.”

They came to consensus around the idea that disclosure requirements should be much higher than they are for members to report their itineraries: “The media will be all over that.”

Here’s The Thing: My students seem to have a better perspective on this topic than 82 percent of the American public. They understand that politicking occurs in politics, and that while some groups may get more access than others, they believe that the best way to curb unethical behavior is to make everyone report their activities to see if they withstand the media spotlight. They feel that vigorous competition and sunshine are better checks on their leaders than more regulations.

In this sense, these students have more in common with the framers of the Constitution than they do with either the generation of liberal political reformers from the 1960s, or some of their conservative parents who first became active with Ronald Reagan in the 1980s. The future may prove interesting indeed. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester at California State University, Channel Islands. She)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 6, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe