Reflecting on last week’s dramatic local and national elections, one thing is clear: affordability, and especially housing affordability, is at the top of a lot of people’s agendas.
Here in Santa Monica, our winning City Council candidates, Lana Negrete, Caroline Torosis and Ashley Oelsen, all recognized the critical need to address housing costs. Negrete and Oelsen also made protecting our neighborhoods and what makes our seaside community special cornerstones of their campaigns. We hope Torosis will join them in giving neighborhoods priority, and we look forward to working with her to do it.
The same message carried up to Sacramento. Brian Goldsmith, our newly elected State Senator, was crystal clear in his campaign about the need for more housing for the middle class, and just as clear about the need to respect our neighborhoods. It’s no coincidence that neighborhoods were a common thread among the leaders voters just chose. Indeed, for much of Sacramento’s recent housing lawmaking, neighborhoods have been an afterthought. Voters, both renters and owners, have been slow to see the threat to their neighborhoods, but they are waking up now.
Some background
Sacramento has passed a raft of new laws in the last several years rezoning cities by increasing density and height standards well above what those cities chose for themselves, often in exchange for only modest commitments to truly affordable housing. The City’s current relative lack of affordable housing did not occur in a vacuum. The State sharply reduced our affordable housing stock by tens of thousands through Costa-Hawkins’ limitations on rent control and the elimination of redevelopment agencies which had been a major source of funding for affordable housing. Had those decisions gone differently, our level of affordable housing stock today would be far larger today.
Recent laws do not purport to materially address these losses. Instead, they’re set to radically change our city’s built environment in short order; indeed, these changes are already arriving in our neighborhoods. A prime example of what’s coming is the seven-story, 102-unit building recently approved for the corner of 32nd Street and Ocean Park, which will overwhelm this neighborhood of one- and two-story homes, with all cars entering and exiting onto one existing low-scale residential street. Such projects are soon to follow across our city. On Pico. On Montana. On Main. On Ocean Park again – and again. And even more change will arrive when the State, in the next few years, makes its next round of assignments, perhaps requiring that we rezone yet again to add more density to the city.
If we aren’t extremely careful about how we implement all this change, it will come at a cost to residents already living here, renters and owners alike, and to working-class and historically marginalized families’ ability to continue living here, and to our city’s appeal for future generations and the tourists we depend on for economic strength.
There’s a real tension among seaside appeal, density, and affordability. Santa Monica’s appeal is in large part why it has become such an expensive place to live. But taking away that appeal by overbuilding our neighborhoods is not a solution. The proposition that if we build units in massive amounts (at market rate), then housing costs will come down might work in many areas of the state but fails to consider the enviable and immutable location of our city. Let’s see the economic studies particular to Santa Monica that support this theory before we continue to pursue this path.
The Neighborhood Taskforce sees this next cycle of government, in Santa Monica and in Sacramento, as a real chance to tackle housing affordability and to make growth work for us, all while respecting the integrity of our neighborhoods.
Where we intend to start
Be clear about what “affordable” means. It doesn’t mean more luxury apartments. We’re well on our way to meeting our state-mandated market-rate goals. It’s homes that working families can actually afford that we’re falling short on. Sadly, we will never be able to replicate the amount of affordable housing that the State legislated away from us over the past decades.
Show us the math. State and regional agencies are now reviewing progress toward our current housing targets, known as RHNA (the Regional Housing Needs Assessment), and setting new ones. What metrics are they using? Are they fair and realistic for Santa Monica? Do they consider the fact that Santa Monica is, and has long been, in the top ten percent ranking of the state in population density and housing density? Based on these and other metrics, Santa Monica has for a long time been doing more than its fair share.
Build where it makes sense. The City’s Realignment Plan calls for shifting density downtown, closer to jobs, shops, and transit. Critically, it also calls for simultaneously lowering the height profile along our boulevards, especially on neighborhood-serving thoroughfares like Ocean Park, Pico, Montana, and Main. Let’s follow through, ease the pressure on our lower-scale neighborhoods, and help revive our core. We can meet our affordable housing obligations without destroying the walkable character of our neighborhood boulevards.
Don’t let developers off the hook but help them build the right things. We’re woefully short on deed-restricted affordable homes. So, is it wise to give builders relief from affordable requirements, which the City has been doing with its off-site affordable housing program? Shouldn’t we be questioning whether the City’s Affordable Housing Production Program is robust enough to meaningfully assist the City in meeting its affordable housing obligations, while also assessing what else can be done to help developers facing high interest rates and tariff-driven costs?
Plan for pipes and pavement. The impact of thousands of new neighbors on our streets, parking, water, and power resources is not inconsequential by any measure. How will we handle this challenge? Are the state and region accounting for that?
Use state law wisely. Santa Monica can do better by:
Matching the state’s tougher affordable-housing percentages in our density bonus ordinance.
Recognizing that developers can usually move above-ground parking underground, significantly reducing a project’s visual impact
Limiting height and size waivers to the minimum needed to deliver the allowed number of homes, so new buildings will fit their neighborhoods. State law does not require more than this.
Creating an opt-in program that rewards builders for delivering 2- and 3-bedroom condos for first-time buyers, especially along our secondary commercial boulevards. That would help young families put down roots here while preserving our lower-density neighborhoods.
We ask these questions and make these suggestions because politics shouldn’t be a zero-sum game. Leadership at its best is as much about listening as it is about advocating for one’s own point of view. Our policy decisions must account for everyone at the table: the new neighbors we will welcome and the neighbors who’ve lived here for decades.
Our city is blessed with good people genuinely trying to help. If they examine these questions thoughtfully and engage residents in a search for win-wins that comply with state law, Santa Monica can show other cities a way forward that brings us together as a community.
These are the things The Neighborhood Taskforce will be working toward in the new year, and we hope our public servants recognize the desire for change along the lines that just shaped our local election.
We look forward to working with all our elected and appointed officials, City staff, neighborhood associations, and residents and wish all a happy holiday season.
____
Loren Bloch on behalf of the Board of The Neighborhood Taskforce
A 501(c)(4) public benefit nonprofit