Skip to content

Los Angeles Go easy on judgments

Published:

By Carmella Cornett Santa Monica

In regard to David Pisarra’s piece (SMDP, Aug. 23, page 4), I agree with your friend’s conclusion that Jews are Jewish by birth and other religions are by choice or faith, although Jews can opt out of the Jewish religion if they wish.

I also agree with you that I am weary of the proselytizing by some other religions. Where I have a little problem with your premise is your leap from Judaism to fundamentalism. There are a lot of people in between who don’t solicit the “likes of Jerry Falwell and Fred Phelps,” both of whom I consider to be borderline dangerous in their ignorance.

To speak of Christians as being in the same category is like saying that all attorneys are shysters and we know that is not so, don’t we?

I am neither a Christian nor an agnostic and I do not subscribe to anything to fit in, as you say many people do. Faith, whatever one perceives it to be, is personal and is not to be bothered unless, of course, except in the case of politicians (or others) who perpetuate their policies (which can affect us all) on the basis of their religious beliefs.

We have seen this in the case of George Bush who feels that his policies are somehow sanctioned by God — not my God, by the way. For the life of me I can’t believe God approves of our country’s invasion of Iraq.

You use the term judgment, judging, etc. quite a bit. It is ironic since that is one of the tenets “preached” in the Bible. You may recall and please forgive my paraphrase: Judge not that ye be not also judged... or something like that.

I note quite a bit of cynicism in your tone, particularly near the end of your article, toward Christianity in general.

Perhaps one of the reasons for the lack of visibility of proselytizing by other religions in this country is that Christianity has been the dominant religion in our country since its birth.

So maybe, as in your friend’s example, people born here, except for the Jews, are born, so to speak, Christian.

There is certainly quite a bit of religious animosity in some other countries, particularly in the Middle East. It seems the Jews have done quite a bit of judging there.

And of course, we are going to be more tolerant of those we care about than those acquaintances in our lives. By the way, I am sorry that you have had a jerk boss with a bald head. What has being bald got to do with being a jerk?

Bottom line, just lighten up and quit judging people so harshly. There will always be good and bad in people, and we are judging and learning when we discern that fact.

I also think you will generally learn more from people with whom you disagree than always being with those who never challenge your belief system, whatever it is.

I have written some of this with tongue-in-cheek. I really did get your point but I’m sure it was lost on many non-thinkers because of your choice of words and tone.

Based upon the quotation of your mother, I have a good idea of the root of your cynicism. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 8, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe