Skip to content

Malibu council keeps fire recovery tax district alive, though most members oppose it

Malibu City Hall or Malibu city council meeting related to fire recovery planning
(Courtesy Image)

The Malibu City Council voted 4-1 on Nov. 9 to keep alive a proposed tax district to help fund recovery in the part of the city burned by the Palisades Fire, even though most of the members who voted yes said they opposed it.

Mayor Bruce Silverstein, who made the motion, said he was voting for it only to keep a promise he made to Danny Smith to support him on rebuilding issues if Smith was elected.

Smith appears to have won a council seat. He led Councilmember Marianne Riggins by 81 votes for the second of two open seats in the Los Angeles County count posted Nov. 9. The county is set to certify results Nov. 27.

“I think that is the wrong decision,” Silverstein said. “But again, I made a commitment, and I’m going to stand by it.”

The motion directs city staff to bring a resolution of intention to form the Malibu Disaster Recovery District to the council’s Nov. 23 meeting, do as little additional work as possible and return the question to the council at its second meeting in January. Silverstein said he hoped the council would then “reverse the decision to go forward.”

Mayor Pro Tem Steve Uhring cast the lone no vote. Councilmember Doug Stewart voted “reluctantly, yes.”

Under state Senate Bill 782, cities recovering from a declared disaster can form districts that capture the growth in property tax revenue as damaged homes are rebuilt and reassessed. The money can pay for infrastructure and projects that reduce the risk of future disasters. Malibu has until Jan. 7, 2027, two years after the governor declared a state of emergency, to start the process.

The proposed district covers about 1,540 acres, roughly 12% of the city, and includes 1,412 properties, 755 of which were significantly damaged or destroyed, according to a staff report. Assessed value in the area fell from about $4.29 billion before the fire to about $3.31 billion afterward, a 23% drop.

Staff estimated the district could generate up to $112 million over its 50-year life if Los Angeles County matches the city’s pledge of 50% of new property tax revenue from the area. The draft resolution would let the city commit up to 75%. Most of that money would arrive in the second half of the district’s term. With the county as a partner, a five-member board of two council members, a county supervisor and two public members would choose projects and could issue bonds.

Stewart, who sits with Silverstein on the council’s Administration and Finance Subcommittee, which recommended against the district, said the projections overstate what the city would gain.

“There is no free money in this. This is our money,” Stewart said. Under the staff report’s 20-year rebuild scenario, he said, $114 million in future revenue is worth about $21 million today, split between the city and the county.

He noted that general fund revenue has grown from $59 million before the fire to $65 million. “It’s like a payday loan,” he said. “We can pay for this in cash, and honestly, we don’t need this district.”

Stewart also objected to county-proposed projects, including water tanks for Water District 29, which he said “raised our water rates 30% to pay for water tanks and infrastructure.” The staff report lists four county water projects valued at $48 million.

He said it is the county, not Malibu, that needs the money.

Uhring said he was “struggling to figure out why I would want to leverage my future against dollars that I don’t necessarily need at the moment.” He also criticized the mayor’s reasoning.

“I just think abdicating your responsibility to make a decision to something that Danny Smith wants to do is a bad move,” Uhring said. “That’s not what you got elected to do.”

Silverstein replied that the election was “largely about people in East Malibu standing up for what they wanted.” He also called the district “fracturing and divisive” because it would set aside general fund money for one part of the city.

Riggins, who voted yes, raised similar concerns and noted that three of the board’s five members would not be elected by Malibu voters. Councilmember Haylynn Conrad said she has “said for two years I don’t want to give up any more control,” but backed the motion because “we could still come back and say no.”

Conrad said she heard in public comment “a desperation for upgraded infrastructure, for the need for water, the need for basic survival in our community.”

Riggins added one more complication: She will miss the Nov. 23 meeting, when the resolution must be adopted. “There won’t be a fifth person here,” she said.

Stewart said no one has identified a project that needs the district’s money.

“This is taking your credit card out and buying something that you’re going to pay for it from your future paychecks,” he said.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 19, 2026. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe