By Brad Busby Playa Del Rey Employee at Le Merigot Hotel in Santa Monica Opponents of EE are lying to you Editor:
For quite some time now, I have been reading the opinions published on Measure JJ. One overriding theme has jumped out over this time, and that is those who are for JJ seem to have no logical arguments in their favor. Yes, in a perfect Utopian world it would be nice to have everybody make more money, with no consequences. Unfortunately, we do not live in an Utopian world, and Measure JJ has some serious consequences.
If measure JJ does pass, prudence (and basic economic common sense) would demand a response from those business affected (mostly Santa Monica hotels). Contrary to popular belief, most of the business’ affected by Measure JJ are not making money hand over fist, and would simply be put out of business if they were to not respond to this attack on their financial well being. A response could come in a number of forms, and will most likely be a combination of a number of adjustments. Two of the most common adjustments hotels (chosen in this particular case because it will be the largest business segment affected) could make to combat a dramatic increase in labor costs, will be either raise their current room rates, or cut back on, and/or replace the affected labor. Let us look at the economic realities and consequences of each of these scenarios.
Many say that in response to Measure JJ, business’ (again we will use hotels) should just raise their prices. These people obviously have no idea how a capitalist economy works. I can guarantee that even right now, before Measure JJ has gone to the voters, if the hotels felt they could raise their rates without seeing an adverse affect on their occupancy they would. It’s simple, if room rates were to rise, occupancy percentages would fall, and the hotels would lose even more money. There is no hotel general manager in this town sitting in their office thinking to themselves “I could be making a larger profit, but why bother.” The fact is, given a raise in hotel rates many consumers would choose areas other than Santa Monica to stay, pure and simple. To even think about raising room rates, you would have to offer something more to guests, i.e. raise service levels, and that will certainly not happen under Measure JJ. Which conveniently brings me to the next point.
Another way the hotels can offset their increased labor costs would be to simply cut back on that labor. In essence, hurting the very people Measure JJ is supposed to help. Labor is one of the largest costs incurred by service oriented business. Which leads them to watch those numbers very carefully, even in current economic conditions. A few extra labor dollars here and there can be the difference between making a profit, and closing the doors. It is obvious that Measure JJ will increase current per person labor costs. Hotels must, and will respond to this simply by not having as many total labor hours. Whether you’re working six people at $6 an hour, or three people at $12 an hour, you’re still spending $36 an hour on labor. Yes, that means people who currently have jobs now, will lose their jobs. This also means that the tourists who come here will experience a decline in the quality of service. Which should, in theory, lead to a decline in occupancy citywide. Another scenario that seems to have been overlooked is the change in the labor pool that will occur. If businesses have to pay a worker $12 an hour, they will look for higher qualifications from that worker. If business are going to pay $12 an hour, they will look for people with college degrees, not high school degrees. Yes, that again means that Measure JJ will hurt the very people it is intended to help.
For those of you who say that you support Measure JJ because you’re looking out for the overworked and underpaid workers in the city, think about this. The fact is most of the workers here in Santa Monica do not live in Santa Monica, and cannot vote on their own fate. Let me also tell you from personal experience that most workers in the hotels do not want this measure to pass because they fear what will happen to their jobs. In other words, if you vote for Measure JJ, your vote could cost many jobs, the very jobs of the people whom you claim to help. Let the people whose jobs Measure JJ are affecting decide their own fate. The people who work for the affected business have a choice for whom they wish to work. We live in a capitalist economy. If they feel they are underpaid, and that their talents will be better rewarded elsewhere, they can find another job. Minimum wages were put into effect in this country primarily to stop the usage of what was in essence slave labor. Any economist will tell you that a government imposed wage that is higher than the naturally economic efficient wage will hurt an economy because it creates inefficiency. That inefficiency is illustrated perfectly by the arguments in this letter. Make no mistake about it, Measure JJ is an attack on the very well being of many business in Santa Monica. They will have no choice but to respond, and the consequences to that will be devastating for this community.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 2, 2002. Read the original PDF.