By RON SCOTT SMITH
Has it really come down to this? For what seemed like an eternity with the wall-to-wall, 24/7 coverage and those ubiquitous news tickers, the 84-year old holy father of Catholicism whiled away his final days, eyeball-to-eyeball with the Reaper (surely for him, not the Grim one most of us must face), as an entire planet was told to hold its breath and brace for the inevitable.
Not skilled in the subtle art of obituary writing, I went searching for a take on the passing of one of the world’s most revered religious leaders while picking my way through the frenzied media onslaught. The temptation to reopen old issues like that of the some 11,000 sexual abuse charges brought forth against his American workforce of priests and bishops had to be respectfully resisted at this time. The buck never did fully stop at the Pope on that, but that’s not the story.
Nor is the story that of the American President rushing off to pay respects to the pontiff, who sent his highest personal emissary to Washington on the eve of the attack on Iraq to try to convince Bush, hell-bent on war, to see the error and perhaps the evil, of his ways. The President has been lavishing praise on the dead John Paul, perhaps spotting political gain, something in which he appears to be fully blessed with 20-20 vision, and has ordered American flags to be flown at half-staff for starters.
His compassion for the fallen holy leader is on full display on the world stage, as he jets into Vatican City with Condie, Clinton and Bush the senior, despite the fact that John Paul’s overriding message for those like Bush was to use that compassion where it’s needed for the living, as in avoiding handing out death in unnecessary wars.
“It’s enough,”
“to piss off the Pope.” — What’s the story? How about having your blood pressure readings crawling across the bottom of television screens all around the world every 20 minutes as you lay there dying? as we used to say growing up angry in Pennsylvania
The President said this before he left for Rome: “The Pope reminded us all of our obligation to build a culture of life in which the strong protect the weak.” His “culture-of-life” thing is starting to really roll now, first through Terry Schiavo, and now the Pope. They’re pulling that term out all over the place to galvanize the new red-state American majority, as the secret that lies beneath it all, the movement to ban a woman’s right to choose how to run her own body, steadily gains steam.
Of course, the “culture of life” for a couple hundred thousand Iraqis turned into a clutter of death in the rubble left by innocently enough named Bunker Busters, Daisy Cutters and the like — ungodly powerful bombs dropped from high flying, state-of-the-art aircraft to hand out freedom in mighty explosions to the fortunate masses below.
That the Pope reportedly had the option to plug into life-support systems that could have prolonged his life, perhaps indefinitely, is not the story either. The decision was made to bow out with courage, grace and dignity, and there was none of the howling that surrounded the Schiavo ordeal, the howling of a right wing activated to the bone, a right wing that seems to choose its targets for compassion based on hidden political gain. Where was Tom DeLay’s powerful voice of protest on the matter of keeping the Pope alive through a feeding tube? But then, Tom DeLay’s right-to-life cherry-picking is not the story either.
The story is that of a media gone wild. Cable news channels and talk radio sleaze artists have suddenly found themselves with power unimagined — the power to not just report and comment on the news, but to create and blow up the news, giving any chosen story life, stature and political sway way above and beyond its due. While this powerful new permutation of the media gives might and weight to stories like Schiavo and steroids, while they pull Jane Fonda out of the cobwebs of history to once again attempt to cut her into little pieces for having had the courage to stand up against another ill-begotten war some 40 years ago, they simultaneously bash what they call the dominant media — the network news, the New York and LA Times, CNN, and other “biased” institutions.
But if you happen to pick up the New York Times today, take note of the restrained news reporting that looks to be almost straining to maintain an objective view of events, all in stark contrast to the shrill, blatantly slanted exclamations coming forth from Fox News, Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity and the rest. Hannity was camped out in Tampa on the street in front of Ms. Schiavo’s hospice for two weeks, as he counted down to her death as though it were a new year coming in. You almost wondered where the dropping ball was.
With all due respect, whether he is your holy father or not, may John Paul rest in peace, away from the shrieking, far from the madding crowd, along with the 1,500 American soldiers and the hundreds of thousands of Iraqis — “culture of life” notwithstanding — whose spirits were forced to rise way too soon. (To reach Ron Scott Smith, e-mail to)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 7, 2005. Read the original PDF.