By CAROLE ORLIN
I am having a lot of back pain lately. It’s hard to describe, kind of like something heavy is on it and is weighing it down. The doctors can find nothing wrong. Finally, after listening to the news one night, I realized my true problem. I am suffering from a syndrome called “severe middle-class taxpayer-itis,” known to occur when the middle class gets saddled with more and more taxes while the rich and poor get to live off our labor. I was able to isolate the news segments that made my pain worse. The subject always seemed to be about illegal immigration and its effects on our health care system. In order to help cure my back pain, I decided to confront the issue of illegal immigration, especially as it impacts health care costs. Knowledge is power, or at least potential power — it depends on what we do with the knowledge.
Immigration always seems to be a hot button issue. For now, I’m only going to focus on its impact on our health care system. I’m not going to discuss the fact that the New Mexico Senate passed a bill ear-lier this month that would allow New Mexico State University students living illegally in the United States to receive financial aid, for which they are currently ineligible. NMSU Provost William Flores said, “If you can give it to athletes or Texans, why not to illegal immigrants? They are simply one more group.” I’m also not focusing on the tremendous effect it has on our schools, jobs, quality of life, etc. No, today I am focusing solely on the impact illegal aliens have on our health care system.
I realize there are many reasons besides illegal immigration for the steep rise in our health care costs: Pharmaceutical companies and their consumer targeted advertising make it very hard for doctors to prescribe generics instead of the costly brand name drugs; inefficiency, mismanagement and waste within the system; not enough focus on prevention and well-care; increase of chronic diseases; malpractice lawsuit awards have greatly increased insurance costs, which of course the patient pays for by increased medical bills. With that said, immigrants factor into this equation in many crucial ways. One out of every four uninsured persons in the United States is an immigrant. Almost half of immigrants have no insurance or have it provided to them at taxpayers’ expense. In some hospitals, as much as two-thirds of total operating costs are for uncompensated care for illegal aliens. Border hospitals reported losses of almost $190 million in unreim-bursed costs for treating illegal aliens in 2000, with another $113 million in ambulance fees and follow-up. Immigrants (both legal and illegal) who arrived between 1994 and 1998, and their children accounted for 56 percent of the growth in the size of the uninsured population in the last 10 years. This increase in uncompensated care for immigrants has forced some hospitals to reduce staff, increase rates, cut back services, and close maternity units and trauma centers.
So much of the focus on illegal immigration now is about tightening up our borders out of a legitimate fear of terrorism. Yet not much ever seems to really be done about it. I recently was watching a news report which played a tape put out by the Mexican government instructing its citizens on how to cross our borders, where the best locations to cross were located, when the best time of year is to cross, what supplies to bring, etc. It is no secret that Mexico depends on the money sent back to it from the illegals in the United States.
Only last Monday, a report was released by private research group, Pew Hispanic Center, which suggests through government data that by March 2004, the nation’s undocumented immigrants rose to 10.3 million. This was an increase of about 23 percent from the preceding four-year period. This would put the undocumented immigrant population now at approximately 11 million. Nearly one-fourth of the total undocumented reside in California. The more I read about our government’s inability or unwillingness to stem the tide of illegal immigration, the more shocked and confused I become. I can’t see how this situation has gotten so out of control. Has the government completely lost concern for its backbone — the middle class taxpayers? Any immigration policy should serve the needs of the citizens of that country. What is our policy? Is it serving our needs? If the U.S. Senate, House of Representatives, and president can enact a bill over the course of a weekend, as was the case with the amazing passage of the Schaivo bill, why has there been persistent inaction in passing any meaningful legislation to control and eliminate the flow of illegal immigrants entering our country every hour? Is the government listening to us, its backbone? Remember when the backbone breaks, the whole structure falls apart. (Carole).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 28, 2005. Read the original PDF.