Skip to content

Misconceptions on Patriot Act widespread

Published:

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY R. STEPHEN KRAMER

Over the past year, the Orange County Register has expressed criticisms in various editorials of the USA Patriot Act (“The House takes a patriotic stand,” June 17; “‘A’ for effort, needs work,” Oct. 17, 2004; and “Welcome limitation on the Patriot Act,” Oct. 3, 2004). The Register’s views reflect common misconceptions of the reforms the USA Patriot Act made to existing laws and how the FBI uses these laws to investigate national security cases.

Contrary to the Register’s views that the act was cobbled together in haste after 9/11, the act actually intelligently addressed laws and policies that had placed unnecessary restraints on the FBI’s ability to gather, analyze and share terrorism-related information. In other areas, the act updated federal laws — written in the era of rotary telephones — to account for new technologies such as the Internet and voice-mail.

Unlike traditional criminal cases, national security cases — where the goal is to protect the United States from the hostile acts of a foreign power — were hindered by investigative tools and unnecessary administrative hurdles prior to the USA Patriot Act. The act applied investigative tools that had been traditionally used in criminal cases to national security matters. Yet, constitutional protections against unreasonable searches are not lessened in a national security case. In both criminal and national security cases, a federal judge must find probable cause prior to any government search where a reasonable expectation of privacy exists.

In a criminal case, there must be probable cause that a crime occurred and that evidence of the crime will be found. In a national security case, there must be probable cause that the subject is an agent of a foreign power — including a terrorist group — and that evidence relating to terrorist activities or foreign intelligence will be found.

Even where probable cause is not constitutionally required, national security cases often require judicial oversight. For instance, Section 215 of the act permits the issuance of a court order for the production of business records.

This technique is analogous to a grand jury subpoena, except a grand jury subpoena doesn’t require the prior approval of a federal judge.

Yet, critics believe Section 215 should exempt libraries despite the fact that criminal investigators have always had this authority through a grand jury subpoena. In the Unabomber case, for example, the government served subpoenas on several libraries to assist the criminal investigation. Section 215 provides agents with a similar tool so that libraries cannot become a haven for terrorists and spies to further their activities with library resources such as Internet access.

The Register also has taken issue with the use of the national security letters. Since 1987, the FBI has issued NSLs to electronic communication providers and financial institutions to learn with whom terrorists and spies are speaking and how they are compensated. Companies served with national security letters are instructed not to disclose the fact that the FBI sought the requested information, as it could jeopardize national security. The non-disclosure caveat was always used with NSLs, and the USA Patriot Act didn’t change this. The act simplified the administrative approval process and made the standard for issuing a national security letter similar to that of a grand jury subpoena.

Most important, the USA Patriot Act allows counter terrorism/intelligence investigators to share information relating to federal crimes with criminal investigators. Prior to the act, it was difficult administratively and legally to share information from a national security case with criminal investigators. Now, when an FBI counter-terrorism suspect engages in illegal acts — bank fraud, drug smuggling, lying to federal agents — the FBI can share that information with criminal agents, who can arrest the suspect and disrupt the terrorist activity long before the suspect can lay his hands on a bomb. (R. Stephen Kramer is an attorney who represents the Los Angeles division of the FBI.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 23, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe