Skip to content

Multi-generational homes have special space needs

Published:

By JODI SUMMERS

Extended families — multiple generations of a family living together under one roof — have been common in many parts of the world for centuries. It’s now a growing trend in the United States.

“Many factors are contributing to the current trend of multi-generational households. First, more people are living into their 90s due to advances in medicine and preventative health. Second, many Baby Boomers have waited until their 30s to start their families. Third, cuts in Medicare and Medicaid, as well as rising nursing home and assisted living expenses, have resulted in many seniors moving in with their adult children,” notes a spokesperson for the East Central Florida Memory Clinic. “Consequently, more than one generation will be living under the same roof at a given time.”

A recent study by Builder Magazine concluded that there are a multitude of reasons U.S. families are now living together. The research team, led by Barbara Nagle and Doris Payne, interviewed eight multi-generational families of different ethnic backgrounds in San Diego, Las Vegas and Orlando.

“Their stories were all different,” Nagle noted.

The only criterion for selection was that the families be multi-generational.

Households ranged from three to seven members. Most of the grandparents were in their late 60s and led independent lives. All were driving and some worked full time. There were no instances of “boomerang” kids — adult children moving back home.

In one scenario, a grandmother moved in to look after her grandchildren because she didn’t want them in day care. Another time it was a decision to pool resources to get a better house. A widowed grandmother wanted to live with her child and grandchild. In another case, the grandparents had recently immigrated to the United States and wanted to live with their child while they adjusted to American life.

According National Survey of America’s Families (NSAF), in 2000, 8.3 percent of children lived in some type of blended families.

It was unanimous that having an older generation in the home was a blessing to the younger generation. Grandparents were viewed as a source of wisdom, experience and love. Being with their grand-children helped them stay connected to the present.

Of the multi-generational households interviewed, only one had the conventional housing solution for multi-generational families — a separate apartment. In most households, the grandparents participated in household activities — cooking and cleaning, or looking after younger children when their parents were not there. One great-grandfather walked his granddaughter to school everyday.

Like most households, multi-generation households tend to congregate around the kitchen and family room. They appreciated niches and extra spaces for computers or tables to spread out homework assignments.

Storage was a big issue — not enough and not the right type. All families included in the survey desired additional storage space in the vicinity of the kitchen for bulk purchases of household goods. Another common complaint was there was no place to store an open 40-pound bag of dry dog food, or a location to feed the dog that wasn’t in the middle of everything.

Privacy was another significant issue. Family members wanted a something akin to the parlors of the Victorian — a place where they could be alone or entertain friends that was not a bedroom. It was noted that families generally respected one another’s privacy.

First-floor bedrooms and entrances for grandparents who were no longer climbing stairs were considered to be highly desirable.

Acoustics are another age-related issue. If a grandparent was hard of hearing and turned up the volume on the television, it was a distraction of other family members.

Children complained that the grandparent they shared a bathroom with took “forever” in the morning.

Overwhelmingly, the biggest issue for multi-generational households was space for home-based businesses. Office needs were not related to the nature of the household, but to the business. Space and storage needs for many of those families extended well beyond a computer work-station and bookshelves.

The Builder Magazine study reported that one family ran a lawn maintenance service and filled its garage with lawn mowers and other lawn equipment. Another family had two businesses — grandpa filled vending machines with candy and needed storage for the candy, while his daughter ran a day care business, looking after other children in the neighborhood. Other families earned income from a variety of cottage industries and needed space for storage and big worktables.

Builder Magazine commissioned the study as background information for its “Multi-Generation Reality House.” The house, designed by the Memphis architectural firm Looney, Ricks, Kiss, will make its debut at International Builders Show in Orlando early next year. (Jodi Summers is director of the investment division at Boardwalk Realty Santa Monica. Contact her at, or call 310-309-4219.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 17, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe