Skip to content

News on the edge

Published:

There’s no debate: Terror scare wins by a landslide

By RON SCOTT SMITH

They’re having a debate tonight but the two guys squaring off are forbidden to address each other directly. Debate? Sounds more like dueling press conferences, but that’s one of the ground rules laid down in an encyclopedic, 32-page official rule book the two sides hammered out earlier this week to ensure that nobody gets real. Why can’t they speak directly to each other, no holds barred, like normal people who have major disagreements over the fate of a planet would do?

No, Americans will not glean much from this thing, which will likely offer little more than fuel for the fire of a popularity contest not unlike those seen in high schools around the nation in electing a student-body president. Who had a bad tie on? Who looked at his watch? Who slobbered? Issues? What issues?

They will talk about the “War on Terror” tonight, of course, and only about it, because the official topic is “foreign policy,” and foreign policy, as well as domestic policy, and every other conceivable policy in Bushamerica is based upon, and justified by, that “war.” Maybe I missed it, but has there been anything else driving American politics in the three-plus years since those mighty towers came down on the most tragic day in the history of this nation? It united us. We retaliated and now stand watch, and we will never forget it. But, now it divides us, and we must get over it.

Might the man who bases his presidency and his reelection on it, explain tonight just what this “War on Terror” is, exactly? Terror is defined in Webster’s as “a state of intense fear.” Might he lay out clearly how you win a war on “a state of intense fear?” And might he be so kind as to tell us how we would know when such a war is over?

Bush refers to terror as if it’s a country to attack. In fact, he has attacked countries in its name. What it is, is desperate statements made through desperate actions by desperate people afraid of losing all they hold dear to them, who don’t have planes or missiles to carry their pay-loads. One man’s terror is another man’s bomb strapped to his chest. One man’s Daisy Cutter falling from a Stealth Bomber in the middle of the night is another man’s terror, and we better get that soon. Somebody better start talking to somebody. Here’s another “W” for you: Wisdom. Where is it? Anybody spotted it recently? That’s real flesh and real blood of young Americans out there on the front lines of this murky campaign, which appears to have no rhyme, no reason. That’s real terror those troops live through every night and day as they patrol the mean, angry streets of a besieged nation whipped into a hateful frenzy by invasion from the West. And that’s real terror the natives live through inside the broken houses in neighborhoods where foreign armies patrol.

“W,” the president by all indications, has neither the words nor the wisdom to guide us through this deadly quagmire of his own making. And John Kerry, caught up in the “fear factor” that now rules the political landscape of America, has apparently decided that he must not distance himself too far from the “Bush Doctrine.” That’s right, he’s got a doctrine named after him — if there’s to be any chance to defeat the sitting president.

They will ask Bush tonight about the prospects for victory and he will say victory is at hand, even as the bombs continue to tear limbs from bodies, and the American casualties continue to mount. He will not be asked about, and it’s best if you don’t think about, the numbers of dead and maimed Iraqi children. They will ask Kerry about his solution, and he may be at a loss. Not because of his own shortcomings on the matter, but because Bush’s operation in Iraq is so totally mismanaged and mangled, that there is really no discernible solution to it in the foreseeable future.

John Kerry has been painted into the same corner Bush has painted us all into, the corner where nobody has a clue and nobody has a door out. New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd nailed down Kerry’s dilemma: “The Bushies’ perverse private calculation about why Kerry can’t get traction would be comic if it weren’t tragic. He can’t effectively argue that he could do something differently in Iraq because W. has so bollixed up the place that even a change at the top wouldn’t help.”

Could that really work? Screw your nation so badly into a tragic foreign misadventure that nobody can unscrew it — so a weary and bewildered populace defaults back to you at election time? Is it a winning strategy?

Heads up tonight, America, as you watch the President of the United States attempt to measure up to the low expectations everyone has set for him. If you squint through the smoke, the blood, the rubble of all the Bush wars, you begin to see the specter of Ashcroft, Pat Robertson, and any number of potential Bush-appointed, ultra-conservative Supreme Court Justices, salivating as they wait in the wings for four more years and a mandate — with fundamentalist social-engineering their divine mission. But that’s not the issue, is it? It’s the terror, stupid. We’re scared, remember? Or is it that we’re safe? I keep forgetting. (Ron Scott Smith is scarred and scared of four more years under the Bush Administration.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 30, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe