By Ed Silverstein
Not unexpectedly, the conversation at a recent party turned to Kobe Bryant’s arrest for sexual assault.
After the prerequisite regurgitation of the assorted rumors and conjecture, I suggested to the eight women and six men that I didn’t believe that “no” always means no.
I was immediately taken to task by one woman who was shocked, aghast even, that I could have made such a statement. But before I could write myself off as a troglodyte who had missed the bus to extinction, the remaining seven women (and to a lesser extent the men) jumped to my defense. These women didn’t believe that “no” always meant “no.” Surprisingly, most of them also felt that a woman who goes to a man’s hotel room in the middle of the night without the express purpose of having sex bore at least some small part of the responsibility for what subsequently occurred.
This is in direct contrast to the hard line feminist rift, such as espoused by Wendy Murphy, director of the Victim Advocacy & Research Group, and CNN’s latest supercilious Gloria Alred clone.
Ms. Murphy, a lawyer, contends that “no” means “no,” period. Even, she insists, if the woman walks into your hotel room naked. “This is the law and there can be no gray areas,” she said.
Ms. Murphy’s legal absolutism is belied, however, by her obvious disdain for one of the most basic tenants of law: Presumption of innocence. Murphy has repeatedly referenced Bryant’s accuser as “the victim” and the incident as “the crime,” with nary an “alleged” to be found. Such statements presume Bryant’s guilt without any benefit of due process.
Ms. Murphy also seems to be out of touch with modern feminism. Since the party, I have talked with dozens of women ranging in age from 20 to 70, career women and stay-at-home moms, and nearly all disagree with Murphy’s “extreme” views.
So when does “no,” not mean “no?” Those queried held the near unanimous opinion that once consensual penetration was initiated (with the stipulation that each act, i.e., intercourse, oral sex, etc., required a separate consent) that there was no basis to claim rape, even if the woman changed her mind. Further, due to the highly charged emotional and physical state during sex, it would be impossible to determine when one reaches a point of no return. Taken to an extreme, imagine a woman changed her mind as the man reached climax and expected him to disengage mid-orgasm.
Another difficulty in determining culpability is the possibility that the woman’s accusation is false. The motivation can range from extorting money to gaining celebrity, or even revenge. A woman can also feel compelled to lie in order to save face or protect herself from public ostracism. Such could have been the case if the parents or friends of Bryant’s accuser were racist, though that is not to imply that this was the case.
So what constitutes rape? Most agree that any form of sex initiated through force, coercion by threat of physical or psychological harm or the administration of drugs or alcohol without the person’s knowledge is rape. But even this is not absolute.
Several of the men I spoke with had had experiences (though extremely rare) with women who pursued aggressive rape fantasies.
These women tend to give mixed, often confusing signals that are designed to initiate a (simulated) rape. A similarly confusing circumstance can occur with certain Asian cultures in which the woman compliments the man by telling him he is too large and that he must stop because he is hurting her.
That is not to say that I am condoning rape in any form. I have cared for rape victims. It is one of the most heinous crimes imaginable. The emotional devastation defies description regardless of whether the woman was chaste or promiscuous, attacked by a stranger in a dark alley or date raped in her home. The scars can be permanent and life altering. And a man who drugs a woman to have sex should be strapped to a tree, horse whipped, castrated, then smeared with honey and staked over a fire ant mound. And any man who disagrees should be treated to the experience of downing a Bud Light and waking up with Andrew Luster giving him a high colonic.
And there is also no question that, historically, rape victims have gotten the short end of the stick. Often they were treated more like criminals than casualties. But more recently the pendulum has swung. There is a tendency now to treat an accusation of rape, or any sexual crime for that matter, as fact. The accused is often deemed guilty and even subsequent exoneration rarely removes the stink. Victims of a false accusation can be equally devastated as those victims of the actual crime.
It is unlikely that we will ever know for sure what occurred between Kobe Bryant and his accuser, and chances are that even if we did there would be no easy answers. For this reason we must insure that we do not rush to judgment and the rights of both parties are equally protected.
We should also avoid dependence on unrealistic myths such as, “no,” always means “no.” It suggests that women have no obligation to act responsibly or be aware of the potential consequences of their actions.
Further, it could embolden inexperienced women to put themselves in risky situations, such as going to a man’s hotel room at two in the morning. And let’s be clear about this, a woman who goes to a man’s hotel room in the middle of the night should not be there to borrow mixed nuts from the mini bar. And for those of you who believe that “no” does always mean “no,” I would deem it prudent that you are 100 percent ready to say “yes” before you put yourself into any situation in which your only protection is a two letter word. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Comments and sensitivity training can be sent to:).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 3, 2003. Read the original PDF.