By Lisa Langlois Santa Monica\
I am a Third Street Historic District resident and I am very disturbed by Greg Poirier's Feb. 13 letter that a property owner's proposed subterranean, on-the-street garage addition was denied because of a personal grudge.
For me, this case was a true exercise in “principles over personalities.” Until the project was opposed by the neighborhood, my husband and I had shared a friendly relationship with the owner and her spouse. In fact, the owner who is a real estate agent, had even graciously advised me on finalizing the purchase of my home in the district. In light of our neighborly-like relationship, it was very difficult to stick by our principles, which meant opposing the owner's proposed project — a project that was uncharacteristic of the neighborhood design.
Sadly, if there is a “grudge,” it seems to have originated from the side of the property owner. The owner and her spouse have refused to even exchange greetings or eye contact since it became known that my husband and I were not in support of their project. Tragically, the owner closed down her side of a shared driveway right after her project was denied. This deprived her disabled senior citizen neighbors access to parking to the rear of their lots (shared driveways are common with the Craftsman design). Despite the city installing a disabled preferential parking space on the street, the disabled neighbors were forced to move because they just could not make it up the incline of the shared driveway nor the stairs to the front of their home.
In reality, the project was not denied because of a grudge. It was denied because a respected preservation consultant, the majority of neighbors, city staff, the Landmarks Commission and the City Council on appeal, all concluded that the garage design was fundamentally uncharacteristic of Craftsman design.
Contrary to Mr. Poirier's claim that the citizen “still has nowhere to park,” there is in fact a city-permitted cement parking pad to the rear of the citizen's house. The citizen not only built the pad, but used it for two of her and her spouse's three vehicles. Recent photographs illustrating the citizen's vehicles parked on the pad were presented at the hearing. The citizen chose to make the pad unavailable so as to create a rear patio. Apparently, the owner's own architect had other design and location alternatives but for some reason, the citizen chose not to pursue them. She has chosen to lease out her house and relocate with her spouse on his boat in Hawaii. The cars, however, will be staying in the neighborhood — in rented garages down the street.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 24, 2003. Read the original PDF.