Skip to content

Non-Prop A alternatives to historical preservation

Published:

By Michael S. Klein

Most of us agree that historical preservation is important. There may be other ways to provide for historical preservation beyond government-sponsored options represented in Prop. A, which was defeated last week.

In other words, there are creative solutions to the problem.

In a perfect world, everyone would agree on the need for cultural and historic preservation. People would all agree on houses and other structures that should be landmarked and everything would be voluntary. Covenants would be recorded on the title of properties that had landmark status and everyone would be happy. But things don’t always work out that way.

Here are a few alternatives that might work. In fact, arguably these alternatives might be preferable to those outlined in Prop. A. And these alternatives are not mutually exclusive. 1. The City of Santa Monica could establish a fund to assist in landmarking of properties. Funds are tight, I know, but read on. The requirements could be minimal. 2. In addition, or as an alternative, a private charitable foundation could be established to assist in landmarking of properties.

The money in either of these two pools could be used in several ways. They could be used to buy properties, record covenants concerning landmarking and re-sell them. They could be used as a financial incentive to an owner to agree to record a covenant. They could be used to acquire alternative property to trade for a landmark property. Or they could be used in some combination of those three ways.

How would this work? First, in a situation involving an owner willing to sell property of historical significance, the city fund and/or the private trust-fund could be used to purchase the property. A simple covenant could be recorded on the title during the period of ownership by the city and/or the private trust, and the house could then be re-sold, with the historical covenant recorded. From that point forward, the house would be a historical landmark by recorded covenant.

In theory, since properties may go up in value with historical covenants recorded (many argue that this would happen, at least over time), and since many people are interested in acquiring historical properties, it is even possible that the property could be re-sold by the city or private trust at a profit.

And if the property could not be sold at a profit, the difference would be proof that the homeowner would have lost money in selling the house as a landmarked house. In that case, it would be only fair that the community as a whole and/or private persons who care enough to contribute to the private foundation should bear the cost rather than the homeowner who bought the property without knowing it would be landmarked.

Second, in a situation involving an owner not interested in selling, but interested in some extra money in consideration of recording a landmarking covenant, the city fund and/or the private trust fund could be used to pay the owner to record a simple covenant. From that point forward, the house would be a historical landmark by recorded covenant.

Third, in a situation involving an owner not interested in recording a covenant or selling, but interested in staying in Santa Monica in a house to be built today, the city fund and/or the private trust fund could be used to finance the purchase of another piece of comparable property not having historical significance or not in the historical district acceptable to the owner for a trade.

The properties could be traded, a simple covenant could be recorded on title during the period of ownership by the city or the private fund, and the historically significant house could then be re-sold, with the historical covenant recorded. The non-significant house could then be developed in a location not having landmark issues. Again, as in the prior example, they might even make a profit for the city and/or private foundation on the sale.

Fourth, a combination of these strategies would be possible.

For example, if the third strategy were employed, but the value of the new property were less than the value of the old property, strategy two could be used to provide some additional compensation. In effect, the owner would be able to trade properties AND potentially have some cash to do the work required.

This type of program could achieve historical preservation in most cases without a majority voting to force something on a minority. All transactions would be voluntary, the costs would be more accurately placed on those who benefit (or think they benefit) and everyone would be happier.

The only logical problem would be the owner in a historical property unwilling, for a reasonable price, to agree to either sell, trade, and/or take a payment to record a historical covenant. If the city still wanted to take a property in those circumstances, condemnation and payment of a fair price as determined by a court might be available.

A lot of people in this community have demonstrated that they really care about this issue. If we can translate that caring into some financial assistance, a program could be implemented along the lines of the strategy suggested above, modified, no doubt, by the many intelligent and caring city staff, commissioners and other caring Santa Monicans in this city that so brims with creativity and people interested in making the world better.

Note that the costs might be recouped from sales except in example two.

As a lawyer, I would be happy to volunteer some of the time needed to implement the private foundation aspects of this and to deal with the legal issues involved if there is interest in pursuing it. (Michael S. Klein is a local attorney and a Santa Monica resident.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 24, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe