This is in response to the article “Parents, students speak up for unity” (SMDP, May 7-8).
First a working definition: “Racism: 1. The belief that some races are inherently superior to others. 2. To include, exclude or select based on race.” Source: Webster’s Dictionary.
I ask this question: Does the Unity Coalition actually have representation of all races within the Unity Coalition?
Haven’t heard any concern with this important and applicable point. If not, then it cannot be called a Unity Coalition. It can be called whatever else is dominant in that coalition. For example, if there was a Unity Coalition that had only whites, that would not be a Unity Coalition. I think it is obvious that the Unity Coalition must actively recruit representatives of all races to participate. It seems funny that no one has pointed this out, perhaps sad as well.
The highlights of the Unity Coalition’s plan definitely is a good start, however far from a completed plan. In the interest of everyone being on the same page I wanted to take a close look in detail, as it was reported in the Santa Monica Daily Press. 1. “The SMMUSD must engage in much greater efforts to address institutionalized racism in the district.” The obvious question has to be: What is the Unity Coalition referring to? Specifics anyone? 2. “Increase outreach and recruitment of faculty of color, who can relate to students backgrounds and life experiences.” White is a color, white is not translucent. And to think that someone can only relate to someone because they’re of the same race is in itself a racist proposition. 3. “Develop a restorative justice approach to student discipline so there is less focus on punishment and more on transformation.” Obviously, if you are a student who prefers to act out in violent ways toward others of different races, you will really love this idea being assured that the focus is not on punishment or expulsion, but on “transformation.” If we are to be honest with ourselves, the focus needs to be on both — a strict and enforced no tolerance, and efforts for rehabilitation, or transformation of the offender(s). 4. “Increase student engagement by celebrating the culture, history and accomplishments of African-American and Latino students.” If you’re going to increase celebrations of culture, history and accomplishments of any race specifically, then it only makes sense to celebrate all races present. Else wise once again, the practice of racism comes to the forefront. 5. “Ensure the curriculum itself and the manner in which it is taught is culturally respectful and relevant.” To be respectful is to encourage one to act from their highest self. To be disrespectful is to encourage one to act from their weakest self. It’s hard to imagine any curriculum at Santa Monica High School that is not respectful of all students in attendance. This definitely needs to be specifically looked at, both the request for ensuring the curriculum and in which the manner it is taught. Otherwise you have a specification that is basically fluff, and insinuates a built-in suspicion of racism. This is hardly a proactive element. 6. “Develop a new protocol on addressing inter-cultural conflict that includes a parental and community involvement.” Hey, that’s something everyone can get behind. 7. “Ensure the efforts are coordinated with middle school reform efforts.” If this hasn’t been thought of already, then definitely it is something we can all support. 8. “Develop a master plan for African-American and Latino student achievement.” Why not develop a master plan for all students’ achievement? Is this to say that there’s only been a master plan for races other than African-American and Latino students? And that’s why they started to fight each other? Of course that is ludicrous, and in this day and age unacceptable. But remember, to select just two races out of the many races that attend our schools for a “master plan” of achievement is in itself a racist proposition. Remember inclusion is the key, not exclusion.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 13, 2005. Read the original PDF.