By Michael J. Tittinger Mike Tittinger is a regular columnist who lives in Santa Monica.
“Two mice are dropped into a bucket of cream,” begins Christopher Walken in the new film “Catch Me if You Can.”
“One quickly drowns. The second mouse keeps swimming and swimming until he churns the cream into butter and climbs out. I am the second mouse.”
Lately, I had been wondering what kind of mouse I am.
Several months ago, I got a call out of the blue from Brian, a childhood friend. As kids we bloodied our knees and noses together playing tackle football in his backyard, as teens we bellowed drinking songs into the frigid Philadelphia sky while downing beers in the woods behind his house.
Brian was the friend we all wanted to be like — tough, popular, good-looking and mischievous. He had a quality about him that made it hard to hold a grudge, a childlike innocence. There was no question he was the leader of his circle of friends.
“Hey, man, I live 20 minutes from you,” he shouted into the phone.
Brian and his wife had moved to Southern California shortly before I did.
They wanted to be closer to her sister. Some 3,000 miles removed from our hometown of Fox Chase, Pennsylvania, we had crossed paths once again. Neither of us knew the other was moving out here. To me, all this was a sign that I had truly found a new home, with familiar faces and hometown comforts beginning to emerge around me on the westside.
I don’t think the feeling was mutual. “I hate it out here,” he said on the phone the other night. “The people are rude … there’s no work. I want a house, and I’ll never be able to buy one out here.”
“I’m sick of being in an apartment so small I can vacuum the whole thing without moving the plug to another outlet.”
He’s been trying to convince “the Mrs.” into moving back East.
I had hoped that he would help me churn butter. Disappointed, I immediately concluded that he was the first mouse, that the cream of the left coast had swallowed him up as it does the stilted dreams of so many who flock here. The pressure and competition was sending him home with his mouse-tail between his legs. He had failed. He couldn’t handle it. My big, tough childhood friend couldn’t take the heat.
What became of the kid who seemed such a natural born leader?
Over the holidays I returned home to Fox Chase and drove past the fields on which Brian and I played football for St. Cecilia Grammar School. Our team was pitiful — winless, even held scoreless for the first couple of games. But the most vivid memories of that team are of a group of kids who finally found the end zone, courtesy of our halfback Brian, and rejoiced as though they had won the district title.
Brian did a flip in the end zone, no small feat for a kid wearing 20 pounds of equipment, igniting a raucous and absolutely ridiculous celebration in light of the scoreboard tally. It didn’t matter. We knew we were losing, but we managed to take pride in what we did achieve that day. We managed to take pride in ourselves for having the wherewithal to enjoy the moment, no matter how fleeting.
And Brian was our ringmaster, making the ordinary extraordinary.
And I remembered the kid who broke up fights in the schoolyard, sticking up for the weaker combatant. And I remembered the popular kid who would pal around with unpopular kids, seemingly oblivious to the snickering cliques. And I remembered the teen-ager who hitchhiked home from the Pocono Mountains (roughly 100 miles north of Philadelphia) in the middle of the night rather than stay in a house where drug use was prevalent.
I was wrong about Brian. We were never the two mice placed into a bucket of cream because he never put himself in that position. Brian didn’t move out West to break into the “industry,” nor does he envision himself as a persuader of public opinion (though he is one).
The truth of the matter is he remains a leader. He embodies all the best things about Fox Chase — community involvement, close-knit families, watching out for one another, planting roots with loved ones. There is something to be said for the ones who shun the glitter of the cream for another bucket altogether, the ones who are oblivious to the snickering cliques.
His is not a case of a small man giving up on opportunity, but rather a big man reconciling with himself about what he wants out of life. In essence, we are one in the same, both chasing our dreams in the places we figure we’ll find it.
Santa Monica is not for everyone. Nor is Fox Chase. My envisioning Brian as the first mouse — the washout — was way off base. He never wanted any parts of the bucket of cream in the first place. It’s not what he’s all about. His decision to depart is what makes him a leader. Brian is not allowing the West Coast to dictate what he wants, he’s doing the dictating and is refusing to settle. He will be a star once again … in Fox Chase.
I’d like to think that I am the second mouse, gaining some footing just by churning away each day on my keyboard. But my friend has taught me that it’s just as important to make sure you’re in the right bucket in the first place.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 9, 2003. Read the original PDF.