By Tom Larmore
(Editor’s note: This is the last in a weekly series of columns by living wage opponent Tom Larmore. The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses in the coastal zone that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees up to $12.25 an hour. Measure JJ asks voters to approve the measure on Nov. 5.)
In this space last Friday, Reverend Frederick H. Borsch, former Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Los Angeles, argued that Santa Monica voters have a "moral right" to demand that Santa Monica's luxury beachfront hotels pay their workers "reasonable and just compensation" and that, therefore, voters should support Measure JJ — the city's Minimum Wage Ordinance.
With all due respect to Bishop Borsch, his arguments reflect the two aspects about this debate that I most resent: the insinuation, sometimes subtle, sometimes not, that opposition to Measure JJ is immoral and the demonization of the "luxury beachfront hotels.”
As I have said many times over the last several months, it is imperative to separate the need to deal with the very real problems of low-income families from the wisdom of Measure JJ -- only the latter is on the ballot. After all, alcoholism was, and remains, a problem in our society and temperance was supported by religious leaders around the country. Did that mean that those who recognized Prohibition as a mistake were immoral?
In evaluating Measure JJ, voters should ask themselves whether an intelligent and effective law designed to actually help low-wage workers and their families would have the following effects:
1. It discriminates against certain employees and employers based solely on their location and level of gross receipts. Why should a law apply to workers on one side of the street but not to those on the other? And what is fair about treating competitive businesses differently based on their levels of sales or location? (Recall that the measure covers employers with over $5,000,000 in "gross receipts," not profits.)
2. It fails to cover employees of unionized businesses. Other than as a method to apply economic leverage to businesses which are targeted for organization by Local 814 of the Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union, what possible purpose is served by permitting unionized businesses, including luxury union hotels like the Viceroy, to pay their employees less than the law requires of others?
3. It risks the loss of part-time and entry-level jobs for our youth. As Allan Young, President of the Santa Monica Boys & Girls Club, said in a recent letter to Santa Monica voters, major local businesses have a history of providing job opportunities for those in need but without skills or experience. At $12-$13 an hour, these jobs will be jeopardized by Measure JJ. Why doesn't the law contain some recognition of this problem?
484,4. It Directs most of the economic benefits to tipped workers with sizable incomes. Current supporters of Measure JJ have admitted in the past that workers earning a major portion of their income from tips should be treated differently from those who don't. Even their favorite economist Robert Pollin, who prepared the economic study on which they so heavily rely, assumed that workers receiving at least one-half of their income from tips would be excluded.
Measure JJ supporters argue that California law precludes including tip income in calculating wages. While this is true for California’s $6.75 minimum wage, the argument depends upon believing that the city has the power to establish its own minimum wage which is 80% higher and apply it only to businesses of a certain size and located in a certain area but cannot treat tipped employees differently. This is absurd.
5. It diverts millions of dollars of tax dollars away from the city's ability to provide fundamental social services to its residents. Do we really think that city employees are underpaid and can afford this additional financial hit on top of its steadily declining revenues?
5E5,6. It risks yet another expensive lawsuit against the city. A few years ago, the city council was warned that its ordinance regulating second units in R1 neighborhoods violated California law. The council passed the law, was sued, lost the suit and had to pay hundreds of thousands of our tax dollars in attorneys' fees. More recently, the council was warned that its regulation of ATM fees was unconstitutional. The council passed the law, was sued and lost the suit. Now we may be waiting for the other shoe to drop in the form of another major attorneys' fee award.
The council has been warned that Measure JJ is also unconstitutional based upon the failure of its discriminatory aspects to honor the constitutional guarantee of equal treatment of the laws. The city attorney has told the council to expect a lawsuit if JJ passes which, if lost, could result in another attorneys' fee award of several hundred thousand dollars, not to mention the expense to the city of defending the measure in court.
Measure JJ is nothing more than an attempt by Local 814 to use governmental power to bludgeon businesses into becoming unionized. The union exemption is the carrot and the inclusion of tipped workers is the stick. In this effort, the union is willing to risk millions of your tax dollars in order to promote its selfish ends.
For all the reasons I have spelled out over 22 weekly columns, voters should just say “no” to JJ.
(Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a local property rights attorney.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 29, 2002. Read the original PDF.