Skip to content

‘One size fits all’ education doesn’t work at Samohi

Published:

By Anne Eggebroten

Santa Monica High School began a dramatic redesign process this fall. Instead of operating as one large high school, it has started to become six small schools on the same campus.

It has been a wild and wonderful couple of months with even skeptics admit-ting that there are many advantages to each 550 students having their own principal, advisers and teacher leader. For one thing, each school “owns” two bathrooms and can keep closer tabs on stocking, vandalism and students hanging out there during class.

Samohi has arrived at this year’s cutting edge of the educational world, and other schools are asking to visit and observe.

Exciting as this change has been, however, one thing has not changed: The one-size-fits-all policy on assigning students to teachers. On this score, Samohi remains in the 1940s.

Courses may be regular, honors/AP, or special ed, but within one type, no requests for changes to a different teacher are allowed, no matter how ineffective the teacher is or how mismatched the particular student and teacher are. Eventually the really bad teachers are processed out of the system, but meanwhile the students to whom they are assigned must sit in their classrooms.

Each year’s computer assignment of students to classes is a lottery. In some classes, you win. In others, you lose. And the results will govern the student’s life for a year.

Educational theory has changed a lot in the past 60 years. Learning styles are known to vary widely. There are auditory, visual and kinetic learners. Some students love to listen to a lecture and take notes. Others need to see things on a page and learn best by reading, while others appreciate dramatic reenactments, films and videos, or power point presentations. Kinetic learners need to participate in a hands-on manner or in some interactive type of classroom.

Teaching styles also vary. Some teachers prepare and deliver careful lectures. Others rely on a textbook while providing learning activities in the classroom. Others use neither textbook nor lecture, but present material through handouts that they ask students to work on in small groups.

Others simply hang out in the classroom and try to be the students’ best friend. For some subjects, such as the freshman humanities course at Samohi, this last method may actually reach a lot of students and engage them in ideas that they might reject in a more formal classroom.

But one size doesn’t fit all students.

However progressive Samohi may be about the structure of the school, it’s not thinking out of the box when it comes to assigning students to teachers. According to the administration, the main reason for absolute inflexibility is the large size of the school.

Samohi Principal and CEO Dr. Ilene Straus has said that the district cannot run a school of 3,500 students and allow students to select their teachers and change when things are not as they wish.

So the problem is fear — a fear that granting students’ requests to change classrooms would result in a deluge of requests that the advisers would not have time to process — and a fear that some teachers would have too many students, while others would have none.

To prevent this from happening, Samohi forces some students to stay in classrooms that just don’t fit. The result is misbehavior, failure to learn, and administrative hours wasted in holding the line against student/parent requests to change teachers.

The school actually has an add/drop deadline, but parents don’t get any letters or computerized phone calls letting them know about this. Advisers don’t tell students requesting a change of teacher that they need to file a blue petition by a certain date. The only clue is one line buried in other announcements: “Sept. 26 — Last day to drop classes with review.” Students who want to change a class, rather than drop the subject altogether, are going to miss this clue. And the school is going to turn down the petition anyway.

But let’s face it. Samohi is the size of a small college. It needs to operate more like a college, letting students know about the add/drop date and allowing students who feel mismatched to move to a different classroom.

Would such a policy really be that difficult to implement? Would it be the end of the world if students in a U.S. history class were allowed to move to an instructor whose teaching style matched their own learning style? Some students might prefer an “easy” teacher. Others might want to take lots of lecture notes and read the whole textbook. Why shouldn’t they be permitted to switch to a teacher matching their needs?

It’s quite possible that most students wouldn’t bother to change teachers — inertia is a powerful factor. It’s also possible that with the students in six small schools, advisers could handle the volume of requests without that much trouble. Maybe 10 percent to 20 percent of the 550 students in a school would come in and request a teacher change. Those could be processed in the first four weeks of class, and all students and teachers would be happier for the whole school year. Even if all the students came in, benefits in learning could create such a sense of satisfaction that no more fires would be set in the bathrooms — taking a huge load off the administration. There would also be gains in student retention.

Finally, let’s consider that other administrative nightmare: What if all students want one teacher?

Samohi currently has one star history teacher: Mr. Michael Felix. He’s young, dedicated and passionate about U.S. history. He begins class with words like, “Today I’m going to tell you the story of …” followed by a dramatization of something like Andrew Jackson versus the Cherokees and the Supreme Court. He uses lighting and music to add to the effect.

So why not let more students into his class, rather than requiring them to sit a few doors away in a less than exciting classroom? Break down a wall, put him in a classroom that holds 60 students. Bring in the other teacher to maintain order and do his or her specialty once in a while, whether it be interactive learning groups or whatever, and to help grade papers and exams. It’s called “team teaching.” If a teacher attracts more than 60 students in one hour, put him or her in Barnum Hall with three or four other teachers to maintain discipline.

This would essentially be a market-based teaching economy. Teachers who are attracting students would be recognized and accommodated. Others whose teaching styles are less popular would continue to do a great job with those students whose learning styles match their own teaching style. Still others would be exposed as not attracting any students.

Yes, it could be a bit rocky transitioning to a high school run like a college, where student demand is allowed to affect enrollment. But, like this year’s redesign, it would have many benefits in the long run. And it’s possible that only a few students would actually want to change classes. Many of them are more focused on their social lives, athletics, or the working world they are about to enter.

Let’s move beyond one-size-fits-all education. Come on, Samo, let’s go! (Anne Eggebroten is a parent and writer in Santa Monica. She is the editor of “Abortion: My Choice, God’s Grace” and is working on a book about raising three daughters).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 13, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe