Skip to content

Ordinance differs from other ‘living wage’ laws

Published:

By Tom Larmore

During the last two weeks, I have described the essential features of the City of Santa Monica’s Minimum Wage Ordinance. One last task is to distinguish the ordinance from so-called “living wage” laws.

This distinction is important because proponents have consistently placed this label on the ordinance even though it is dramatically different and, therefore, will have very different impacts.

Baltimore adopted the first “living wage” law in 1994, which covered employees of companies entering into contracts with the city worth at least $5,000.

This type of ordinance — referred to as a “contractor only” ordinance — is the most common. More recent laws have expanded the base of covered companies to include firms receiving some form of financial assistance, such as tax incentives, in excess of a designated level — $100,000 in the case of Los Angeles, Oakland and San Jose. Only a very few cities have adopted laws that include city employees.

When limited to companies doing business with the city, these laws have a reasonable basis and, even if not the best way to help alleviate poverty among low-wage workers and their families, at least plausibly have this effect.

A large city such as L.A. enters into service contracts paying millions of dollars annually. Normally, these contracts would be awarded to the lowest competent bidder. Supporters of “living wage” laws contend that in many cases, workers performing the required services are paid wages insufficient to provide for their families. Therefore, they must rely on governmental assistance.

It seems incongruous to have a system in which workers must seek additional governmental support when their wages are, at least indirectly, paid by the city. Therefore, it is reasonable for a city to require that wages be raised to avoid this result.

It is more efficient and realistic for the city to insist that wages be higher even if the result is a slightly higher contract price — the city is paying either way.

The “contractor only” ordinances are much like “prevailing wage” laws that require municipal contractors to pay, at least in some cases, wages higher than those that might be paid in a totally free market.

For this reason, they are supported by unions representing municipal workers in order to reduce the incentive for out-sourcing work to private companies.

The same theory holds when the ordinance extends to companies receiving financial assistance. These are companies the city hopes to attract because of the jobs created and tax revenue expected to be produced.

However, if the workers will be added to relief roles, the city will not be getting what it bargained for and the economic consequences of the higher wage can be taken into account in negotiating the terms of the assistance to be provided.

In contrast, Santa Monica’s ordinance, as discussed in this column two weeks ago, applies to all service contractors irrespective of the amount of the contract, and to city employees but does not apply to companies receiving financial assistance.

This difference may be because of the extensive amount of money given by the city to nonprofit organizations, which would be hampered if they were required to pay wages at the level mandated by the ordinance.

Most importantly, of course, the city’s ordinance also extends to private companies having no business relationship with the city simply because of their location and sales volume. As a result, the ordinance is actually a hybrid, with some aspects of a typical “living wage” law while resembling a minimum wage law that increases the minimum wage by more than 80 percent from $6.75 to $12.25 per hour.

It is this unique character which must be considered when assessing the likely impacts of the law — a subject I will turn to next week. (Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a property rights attorney.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 9, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe