Skip to content

Outsourcing challenges American livelihoods

Published:

By COMMON SCENTS BY CAROLE ORLIN

It’s been nearly a year since my last column about outsourcing/offshoring (SMDP, February 14, 2005). The issues that surround outsourcing have not gone away. They have only gotten more complicated for all of us: as employees, as business owners, as stockholders, as consumers and as Americans.

My earlier focus was not only on the financial devastation of outsourcing to the American worker. I questioned the safety of outsourcing the maintenance of our airplanes to countries with more lax requirements for their mechanics, coupled with lack of regulatory oversight. I highlighted examples, such as the 2003 commuter flight crash in Charlotte, N.C., that killed 21 people. Deficient maintenance by an outside vendor and lack of regulatory oversight were ruled partly to blame. In 1999, the ValuJet flight 592 crash was attributed to oxygen canisters improperly stowed in the airplane’s hold by employees working for an outside contractor. Other safety concerns appeared to point to the possibility of terrorist infiltration into the airline shops. I looked at an incident in 2001 with SASCO, the company that works on Northwest Airlines DC-10s in Singapore. Authorities there arrested 13 people suspected of having ties to Al Queda, and one of them was an aircraft technician.

I’ve been closely following the continued growth of outsourcing since the dot-com bubble burst. Forrest Research estimates that the number of U.S. computer jobs moving overseas will reach more that 472,000 by 2015. The Communications Workers of America (CWA) estimates that we have already lost 400,000 white collar jobs to offshore outsourcing and estimates that more than 3 million white collar jobs will be lost to this phenomenon by 2012.

The real confusion and difficulty with offshore outsourcing comes with the significant impact it has on all of us, with great differences relating to which “hat” we may be wearing: an employee being laid off from a U.S. company, an employer or business manager of a U.S. company, a stockholder (perhaps one tied to a 401K) of a U.S. company, a consumer of a U.S. company. The genie is out of the bottle; there is no turning back from the global economy that exists in the 21st century. We need to be more aware of the actions that companies are taking with offshore outsourcing.

Companies that are outsourcing to remain competitive need to be held accountable to the employees they are laying off. If the employees are fired because someone overseas will do the same job for less, there should be substantial, not token assistance provided. This assistance should encompass something more than short-term financial help. Perhaps the answer will lie with worker re-education and alternative job placement. As consumers, we should all keep informed of the scope of outsourcing by the companies with whom we do business. We need to know whether our computer choices (like IBM, Hewlett-Packard and Dell Inc.) and our banking choices (like Bank of America, Washington Mutual and Wachovia Bank) and a myriad of others are outsourcing. Those that I have enumerated are but a small sampling of those that do outsource. Then, we need to investigate how these companies have treated their former employees and evaluate how the out-sourced employees are treating us as customers.

Not all companies are outsourcing their work. For example, 1-800-Flowers.com tried a pilot program for customer services in India. The executive in charge, Lou Orsi, discovered within weeks that it was a disaster. The company quickly realized that customer service was both psychology and technology. Finding that the overseas employees were difficult to understand, the company feared lost sales and were concerned with that risk. They decided to keep the phone work in the United States, and continued to outsource some e-mail work, as the highly educated Indians performed very well in that area.

Still, attempting to cut costs, the company decided to work with a U.S. company that specializes in a new trend called “homeshoring.” This simply means moving customer service jobs out of high overhead call centers and into the workers’ own homes here in the United States. Highly visible, JetBlue Airways is already doing just this. All of its 1,400 reservation agents work from home. The companies save money, as they do not need to provide a call center, office supplies, etc. The employees are independent contractors. The drawbacks for the workers include having to pay for their own health care, computer equipment, training, background checks, etc. Despite this, home-shoring jobs are expected to reach 330,000 by 2010. Office Depot, McKesson Corp. and J.Crew, to name a few, utilize home agents. It is felt that homeshoring omits “accent fatigue, cultural disconnection and customer rage,” not to mention the ever-increasing security concerns that are so common with offshoring. According to a recent article in Business Week (January 23, 2006), these home workers, or cyber-agents, are better educated than their counterparts in call centers: more than 75 percent have some college education, compared to 20 percent of call center workers. Obviously, home-shoring is not the solution for all jobs that are being lost to outsourcing (offshoring), but this is an encouraging trend.

It is important for our government to help us in some way in dealing with this complex problem. However, I am highly skeptical that our elected representatives are not themselves highly susceptible to influence by the large companies and their lobbyists. I am skeptical that they will act objectively and fairly balance everyone’s interests. Like many other issues, it may rest squarely on our shoulders as consumers and as shareholders to become much more proactive. This is a very difficult, multifaceted problem that is not going to go away. The reality points to the fact that the workplace is global, and many millions of hard-working Americans are losing their livelihoods through no fault of their own. I wonder why we do not see this issue addressed on a regular basis. We must face the challenges together; we cannot ignore them. (Carole)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 30, 2006. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe