By Robert Berger Committee For Smoke-Free Parks
In his July 19 Daily Press opinion piece, Mike Tittinger accuses me, the City Council, and the Recreation & Parks Commission of blowing “smoke up our asses” in pushing for healthier and cleaner parks by banning smoking. While I could suggest ways for Mr. Tittinger to make his arguments less crudely, I do want to respond to a number of his misstatements.
First of all, no one is “mulling over” a measure that would ban smoking in and around children’s playgrounds. A new state law went into effect last January that establishes this ban in all California parks, including those in Santa Monica. What is being mulled over is a Santa Monica policy that goes beyond this new state minimum requirement to ban smoking throughout the parks. This is exactly what the city of Beverly Hills did in a move that was widely praised and has met with virtually no compliance/enforcement issues. The Recreation & Parks Commission voted unanimously, at its June 20th meeting, to support such a curb-to-curb policy.
The public hearing that preceded the vote demonstrated overwhelming community support for such a policy. The American Lung Association, the American Cancer Society, the Boys & Girls Clubs of Santa Monica, and many other local organizations have come out in support of this measure. They have done so not because this is a “feel-good, tree-hugging measure” as Mr. Tittinger characterizes it, but because it is good public health policy. A front page story in the June 20th L.A. Times reported alarming new research that smoking is a “deadlier carcinogen and causes more types of cancer than previously believed.” The comprehensive study by the United Nations International Agency for Research on Cancer also provides the first definitive evidence that secondhand smoke causes lung cancer, increasing the risk to those exposed by about 20 percent.
Mr. Tittinger would have you believe that because you are outdoors, you are not subject to the negative effects of outdoor smoke. I guess he would also argue that we don’t have to worry about automobile or bus emissions because “it’s a big atmosphere.” The truth is that secondhand smoke is a health hazard outdoors, particularly in areas where people gather to play, eat and enjoy other park activities. A study presented at the 2002 Pediatric Academic Society annual meeting showed that the nicotine content measured by analyzing the hair of children was relatively high among children of parents who only smoke outside of the house. It also makes simple common sense that when you are smelling someone else’s smoke, it means that you are taking that person’s unfiltered smoke into your system.
Mr. Tittinger also conveniently ignored the litter problem caused by discarded cigarette butts. Perhaps he closed his ears when Dr. Lori Kaplan testified at the public hearing about her young son almost choking on a cigarette butt he picked up in a Santa Monica park. Mr. Tittinger is correct that I stated that smoking doesn’t fit in with the healthy activities that our families enjoy in our parks. We know that children model adult behavior. We don’t allow the drinking of alcohol in our parks. Why should cigarettes be any different?
Even though Mr. Tittinger claims to like his bars “a little dank and seedy,” he says that he is “working through” the ban on cigarettes in bars and restaurants. My hope is that Mike will also be able to work through the ban of cigarettes in our beautiful parks, an idea that is good for his health and for the health of all Santa Monica residents.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 24, 2002. Read the original PDF.