By CAROLE ORLIN
I recently caught a segment of Bill O’Reilly (you know, the guy you love to hate) when he was interviewing that old photo-op hound, Geraldo Rivera.
O’Reilly was interviewing Geraldo about illegal immigration. Good old Geraldo played the race card and stated something to the effect that if these were white people crossing the borders, Americans would be OK with it. He seemed to ignore the fact that people are bothered by this unprecedented number of illegal immigrants and the impact it is having on our economy, schools, health care system, legal system, not to mention the serious risk of allowing terrorists and drugs into our country. Is this concern driven by the color of their skin? Geraldo asked why there are not Minutemen guarding the northern borders. Actually, the Northern Guard is guarding the northern borders. The truth is that there are millions of illegals crossing the southern border. Although any illegal crossing is cause for concern, the fact is, there are significantly fewer people crossing the northern border. It’s a matter of numbers, not racism. People are so afraid of being called racist that they become hobbled with fear and don’t speak out about issues that are so important to our country.
We are a country of immigrants, and we are proud of that fact. Has Geraldo forgotten the concept of legal immigration? If illegal immigration is condoned, what illegal act will be acceptable in the future? Are we supposed to ignore the fact that illegal immigrants now outnumber legal immigrants, according to a new report from the Pew Hispanic Center in Washington? Or, that in the past 12 months, the number of illegals apprehended near Tuscon alone numbered more than 435,589? That is the size of a decent-sized city. And that number only represents the ones who were apprehended in that one sector alone. According to a recent article in Business Week magazine (Oct. 10, 2005), the border patrol agents in the Tuscon sector, where temperatures can get to 130 degrees Fahrenheit, have aluminum canopies for shelter, with no air conditioning, only water cooled outdoor fans, no land line telephones, cell phones that do not always work, computers rigged to car batteries and not connected to headquarters data banks. This is just overwhelming information. What does it say about the support these agents are getting? How can they possibly do their jobs, which are almost impossible under the best of circumstances?
Our ancestors were all immigrants, but they came to this country legally and proudly embraced their new home. Assimilation was a goal. People were proud to become Americans. My mother often told us kids how proud she was when she became an American citizen. She never stopped loving Canada, the country of her birth, but she was as red, white and blue as they come. Assimilation is now a bad word for many immigrants, as it means embracing the “evil empire,” despite the fact that this country provides them with more than their country of origin. The wonderful thing about living in a democracy is the freedom to criticize, which heaven knows I do, but I also to try to be part of the solution. I am proud of my roots, but I am not rooted in the past. I see myself as an American, and not a guilt-ridden, self-hating American. I will continue to constructively criticize what to me seems wrong, temper it with an appreciation of what I have, and work for a solution. Give up the dream of a perfect utopian country. Human beings run the country, and human beings, by definition, are imperfect. So instead of just criticizing, do something constructive to make things better.
It’s not politically correct to criticize illegal immigration, but the government’s policy, or lack thereof, has led to frustration and anger amongst its citizens. State and local governments are left to deal with these situations as best they can, which frequently creates more confusion and frustration. When something is enforced by one entity or agency and the federal government refuses to do its part, chaos, confusion and anger are sure to follow. When you see the impact that the unprecedented amount of illegal immigration is having on our country, coupled with the fact that our own government refuses to do anything meaningful, it seems logical for people to try to deal with it themselves. I don’t think that this is the right way to handle it, but it is an understandable result of a built-up of frustration stemming from the realization that government is not doing anything to enforce its alleged policy toward illegal immigration. It seems more risky to ignore its impact until it’s too late to do anything about it. Why is the federal government so silent about this issue, and why is it leaving each state, county and individual to twist in the wind? It’s a recipe for trouble. (Carole)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 7, 2005. Read the original PDF.