I am continually appalled by the gap between the beauty of the setting of Santa Monica and the ugliness and meanness of so many of the people here. So many of them appear in your letters to the editor.
And now this brutishness is appearing in your columns. Before I proceed, let me ask you something about Mr. David Pisarra’s “Legal News and Views” column (SMDP, July 27, page 5). Why the word “legal?” It just seems like political opinion, and, in the most recent column, a particularly low and tasteless form of political argument.
I refer to his attack on Ken Genser’s appearance and drawing a parallel between his appearance and his right to opine on the appearance of new buildings in the city.
“I’d like to know where a public figure who dresses the way he does,” Pisarra said, is entitled to declare that the Architectural Review Board “should have the right to review a proposed home design.”
To drag in Martha Stewart and suggest that she was sentenced to jail for trying to be “the arbiter of good taste and design” surely doesn’t show a rigorous legal mind on the part of Mr. Pisarra, nor does it advance his argument against City Councilman Ken Genser.
Nor does his final argument that if Mr. Genser dares suggest that a board of the city dedicated to reviewing the architecture of buildings (not simply a review of their building for safety) should have the right to prevent an ugly building, then Mr. Pisarra should have the right to take over Genser’s dressing — his shoes, his pants, his shirts, his health regimen, and his grooming — how he appears in the world. What he eats, who he is seen with, what car he drives, and where he shops.
Let me try to follow this: Since Mr. Genser does not dress or groom himself the way Mr. Pisarra wishes, he should shut up on even general statements about some building designs being ugly and that a City Council board should have the right to review such a building design. Does Mr. Pisarra really believe that the elected city officials and their appointed boards simply say that anything goes when it comes to appearance of buildings in the city?
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 30, 2004. Read the original PDF.